Battlefield Atlas
Plains Wars · 1876 First 3 stages free

Battle of the Rosebud, 17 June 1876

On 17 June 1876, Lakota and Northern Cheyenne warriors — led, by their own accounts, by Crazy Horse, Two Moons, Young Two Moons, Spotted Wolf and others — struck Brig. Gen. George Crook's column of about 1,000 soldiers and some 260 Crow and Shoshone allies as it halted on Rosebud Creek in southeastern Montana. For about six hours the fight surged across some ten square miles of ridges and coulees: the Crow and Shoshone held off the first rush, Crook seized the ridge since called Crook's Hill, and Lt. Col. William Royall's battalion was nearly cut off on the ridges west of Kollmar Creek while Crook sent Captain Anson Mills down the Rosebud after a village that was not there. The warriors finally broke off, and Crook held the field, but he withdrew to Goose Creek and out of the campaign. Eight days later the same camp fought Custer at the Little Bighorn. Warrior numbers are given from about 750 to 1,500 (Mills estimated 1,000–1,500 in front of him); losses on both sides are disputed. Four soldiers of the 3rd Cavalry received the Medal of Honor: Trumpeter Elmer A. Snow (Troop M) and First Sergeants John H. Shingle (Troop I), Michael A. McGann (Troop F) and Joseph Robinson (Troop D). The Cheyenne call it the Battle Where the Girl Saved Her Brother. Much of the field is preserved as Rosebud Battlefield State Park, a National Historic Landmark. Unit positions are approximate.

Play the first 3 stages free7 stages on modern satellite imagery and terrain, with 3D elevation

The first 3 of its 7 stages are free to play. The rest opens with Battlefield Explorer ($4.99 a month or $39 a year), which unlocks every battle in the atlas and every one added later. Lifetime access and war packs are one-time options. Free battles include Thermopylae, Plataea, Actium, Viking raid on Lindisfarne, Hastings, Hattin, Agincourt, Vítkov Hill, Kutná Hora, Fall of Constantinople, First St Albans, Lützen, Siege of Buda, Culloden, Fort William Henry, Yorktown, Lake Erie, Waterloo, The Alamo, Monterrey, Antietam, Little Bighorn, Manila Bay, Belleau Wood, Saint-Mihiel, Omaha Beach, Inchon, Ia Drang, Goose Green, 73 Easting, Wanat, Baghdad Thunder Runs, Manbij, Battle of Raqqa, Donetsk Airport, Ilovaisk, Debaltseve, Battle of Kyiv, Battle of Hostomel Airport, Siege of Mariupol, Bilohorivka (Siverskyi Donets crossing), Kharkiv counteroffensive, Kherson counteroffensive, Bakhmut, Vuhledar, Mala Tokmachka and Robotyne, Avdiivka, Kursk incursion.

The Sioux charging Royall's cavalry
The Sioux charging Royall's cavalry — Charles St. G. Stanley, public domain

The battle, stage by stage

  1. 17 June 1876, about 8:00 AM

    Coffee on the Rosebud

    Brig. Gen. George Crook's Big Horn and Yellowstone Expedition, roused at 3 AM and on the march by 6, comes down the south fork of Rosebud Creek into a valley where the stream runs east for nearly three miles. About 8 AM Crook halts: horses are unsaddled to graze and men make coffee along both banks, while he waits for his Crow and Shoshone scouts on the ridges to the north. He has roughly 1,000 soldiers — fifteen troops of the 2nd and 3rd Cavalry and five companies of the 4th and 9th Infantry, the infantry riding mules — with about 175 Crow and 86 Shoshone warriors under Old Crow, Plenty Coups, Washakie and others, and about 65 Montana miners and some 20 packers. Over the hills to the north, Lakota and Northern Cheyenne warriors who rode through the night from their village on the upper Reno (Ash) Creek drainage are closing in. Crook's Hill and Conical Hill are placed from the state park's map and the terrain; unit positions are fitted to that ground from the narratives and are approximate.

  2. About 8:30 AM

    'Heap Sioux!' — the scouts' fight

    Shots on the northern ridges: the Crow and Shoshone scouts come racing back shouting 'Heap Sioux!' with warriors close behind. Their fight on the slopes north of the creek — a running, mounted battle — slows the attack and buys Crook the minutes he needs. Captain Frederick Van Vliet's two troops of the 3rd Cavalry climb the high bluffs south of the creek to secure the rear; Major Alexander Chambers's infantry and Captain Henry Noyes's 2nd Cavalry battalion form a dismounted skirmish line north of the stream; and Captain Anson Mills's 3rd Cavalry troops mount and charge the first ridge. Among the warriors that morning, by Lakota and Cheyenne accounts, are Crazy Horse, Two Moons, Young Two Moons, Spotted Wolf and Jack Red Cloud, whose pony was shot by the Crow and who was quirted by them as he fled on foot.

  3. About 9:30 AM

    Crook's Hill and the ridges

    Mills charges a second time and takes the broad ridge north of the creek, ever since called Crook's Hill, where Crook sets up his headquarters. The warriors fall back to the next high ground, including a cone-shaped knoll that Kingsley Bray's account puts about three-quarters of a mile to the northwest (Conical Hill), and keep returning. In Mills's second charge his trumpeter, Elmer A. Snow of Troop M, 3rd Cavalry, is carried into the warriors by his bolting horse and shot through both arms; his Medal of Honor citation reads simply: 'Bravery in action; was wounded in both arms.' On the left, Lt. Col. William Royall, Crook's second in command, takes Captain Guy V. Henry's battalion and Andrews's troop west across the Kollmar Creek valley onto the ridges beyond, pursuing too far. The miners and packers fight from rocks near the center.

  4. About 10:30–11:30 AM

    Royall alone; Mills sent for the village

    Believing a large village lies close downstream, Crook orders Mills and Noyes — eight troops, about 400 men, with the scout Frank Grouard — off the high ground and east down the Rosebud to find and strike it (timings are approximate and accounts differ; Mills recalled the order as about 12:30), and recalls Van Vliet from the south bluffs. Two infantry companies are detailed toward the hill nearest Royall to support him with long-range fire (their exact position is not certain). But Royall's battalion, about a mile to the northwest beyond the Kollmar coulee, is now the target: warriors work around it from three sides, and Captain William Andrews's Troop I, pushed out to a point beyond Royall's line, has to fight its way back. Ordered to rejoin Crook, Royall sends back only Captain Charles Meinhold's troop, by one account judging a full withdrawal under that pressure too dangerous.

  5. About 11:30 AM–12:30 PM

    Royall's withdrawal

    Royall falls back southeast along the ridge to a second position, under attack from three sides, then makes a dash down into the Kollmar ravine and across it toward Crook's Hill. This is the heaviest fighting of the day: Royall's command takes most of the army's casualties, Captain Peter D. Vroom's Troop L suffers the heaviest proportional loss of any company (Mills), and Captain Guy Henry is shot through the face; Henry later credited Washakie's Shoshone with standing over him until he could be carried off. First Sergeants Joseph Robinson (Troop D), in charge of the skirmish line, who brought up the lead horses at a critical moment, and Michael A. McGann (Troop F) later received the Medal of Honor for this fight. A Crow and Shoshone counter-charge and long-range infantry fire cover the crossing. In this fight, by Cheyenne tradition, Buffalo Calf Road Woman rode in to rescue her unhorsed brother, Comes in Sight, which gives the battle its Cheyenne name, 'Where the Girl Saved Her Brother.' Meanwhile Mills and Noyes are miles away, descending the narrow canyon north of the Big Bend.

  6. About 12:30–2:30 PM

    Mills recalled; the warriors break off

    Crook sends his aide, Capt. Azor H. Nickerson, to recall Mills: there is no village close by — the camp lay many miles to the northwest. Mills climbs out of the canyon and returns across the uplands, reaching the field about 2:30 PM behind the warriors still facing Crook's Hill; accounts differ on whether he came back through the canyon or across the tableland. The Lakota and Cheyenne, who have fought for about six hours, break off and ride away to the north. Crook holds the field. His report gives nine or ten soldiers killed and 21–23 wounded, with one scout killed and seven wounded; Lt. John Bourke counted 57 casualties (four wounds mortal), and the scout Frank Grouard claimed 28 killed and 56 wounded. Warrior losses are given anywhere from at least eight dead to 36 killed and 63 wounded, a figure later attributed to Crazy Horse.

  7. 17–18 June 1876

    Back to Goose Creek

    Crook's men camp on the battlefield, bury their dead near the creek, and tend the wounded. Short of rations and ammunition, with wounded to carry, Crook turns back on 18 June and withdraws south to his supply camp on Goose Creek, near present-day Sheridan, Wyoming, reaching it about 19–21 June; the wounded later went on to Fort Fetterman, and the column stays in camp for weeks. The Crow and Shoshone go home. Crook claims a victory because he held the field, but his column is out of the campaign, and he sends no word that reaches Brig. Gen. Alfred Terry. Eight days later many of the same warriors fight Custer's 7th Cavalry at the Little Bighorn. The withdrawal route on this map is schematic.

Forces

Crook brought about 1,000 soldiers, 261 Crow and Shoshone warriors and some 65–80 armed civilians, more than 1,300 in all. Estimates of the Lakota and Cheyenne warriors run from about 750 to 1,500; no count was made, and the warrior figures are estimates.

Lakota and Northern Cheyenne warriors

Warriorsabout 1,000 (750–1,500)

White Bull's account (via Stanley Vestal) says almost a thousand warriors assembled; Anson Mills estimated 1,000 to 1,500 in front of him; True West gives 750 to 800 mounted warriors; Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks gives 1,000 to 1,500. White Bull's account, in Bruce Brown, 100 Voices from the Little Bighorn; Anson Mills, recollection (1917), in Bruce Brown, 100 Voices from the Little Bighorn; True West Magazine, Battle of the Rosebud; Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks, Rosebud Battlefield 150th commemoration program (2026)

Brig. Gen. George Crook's column (2nd and 3rd Cavalry, 4th and 9th Infantry) with Crow and Shoshone allies

Whole column (soldiers, allies and civilians)more than 1,300

The staff ride atlas says more than 1,300 soldiers, Indians and civilians left Goose Creek on 16 June; Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks says about 1,300 soldiers and scouts. Charles D. Collins Jr., Atlas of the Sioux Wars, 2nd ed. (Combat Studies Institute, 2006), Map 18; Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks, Rosebud Battlefield 150th commemoration program (2026)

Soldiers (15 cavalry troops, 5 infantry companies)about 1,000 (about 990–1,051)

HistoryNet says just under 1,000; True West about 990 cavalry and mule-mounted infantry; the column numbered 1,051 when it left Fort Fetterman on 29 May. HistoryNet, 'The Battle of Rosebud A to Z'; True West Magazine, Battle of the Rosebud; Charles D. Collins Jr., Atlas of the Sioux Wars, 2nd ed. (Combat Studies Institute, 2006), Map 17

Crow and Shoshone warriors261 (261–266)

The staff ride atlas gives 261 allies; True West 175 Crow and 86 Shoshone; HistoryNet 180 Crow and 86 Shoshone. Charles D. Collins Jr., Atlas of the Sioux Wars, 2nd ed. (Combat Studies Institute, 2006), Map 18; True West Magazine, Battle of the Rosebud; HistoryNet, 'The Battle of Rosebud A to Z'

Armed civilians (miners and packers)about 65–85

HistoryNet counts 65 Montana miners and 20 packers; the staff ride atlas says about 80 civilians had joined. The 1972 National Register nomination gives some sixty-five miners. HistoryNet, 'The Battle of Rosebud A to Z'; Charles D. Collins Jr., Atlas of the Sioux Wars, 2nd ed. (Combat Studies Institute, 2006), Map 18; NPS, National Register nomination, Battle of the Rosebud (1972)

Casualties

Crook reported about 10 killed and 21–23 wounded, most of them in Royall's command, plus one allied scout killed and seven wounded; Bourke counted 57 casualties in all and Grouard claimed far more. Lakota and Cheyenne losses are poorly known: 13 dead were left on the field, Bray says at least eight died, and Crazy Horse is said to have given 36 killed and 63 wounded. Certainty: fair.

Lakota and Northern Cheyenne warriors

Killed (left on the field)13

The Army's staff ride atlas counts 13 Lakota and Cheyenne dead left on the field; the Crow reportedly took 13 scalps. Charles D. Collins Jr., Atlas of the Sioux Wars, 2nd ed. (Combat Studies Institute, 2006), Map 23; Wikipedia, 'Battle of the Rosebud' (leads only)

Killed (Lakota-centered biography)at least 8

Kingsley Bray writes that at least eight warriors were dead and many more seriously wounded, among them the mortally wounded Black Sun. Kingsley M. Bray, Crazy Horse: A Lakota Life (2006), excerpt in Bruce Brown, 100 Voices from the Little Bighorn

Killed and wounded (attributed to Crazy Horse)36 killed, 63 wounded

A figure Crazy Horse is said to have given later; how such a precise count was produced is questioned, and other estimates of the dead run from about 10 to 100. Charles D. Collins Jr., Atlas of the Sioux Wars, 2nd ed. (Combat Studies Institute, 2006), Map 23; True West Magazine, Battle of the Rosebud; Wikipedia, 'Battle of the Rosebud' (leads only)

Brig. Gen. George Crook's column (2nd and 3rd Cavalry, 4th and 9th Infantry) with Crow and Shoshone allies

Killed (U.S. Army)9–10 (9–28)

Crook's report gives nine or ten soldiers killed (the staff ride atlas says 10; HistoryNet reads it as nine soldiers plus one Indian scout). The scout Frank Grouard claimed 28 killed. Charles D. Collins Jr., Atlas of the Sioux Wars, 2nd ed. (Combat Studies Institute, 2006), Map 23; HistoryNet, 'The Battle of Rosebud A to Z'

Wounded (U.S. Army)21–23 (21–56)

Crook's figure is given as 21 (staff ride atlas, True West) or 23 (HistoryNet, Bray); the 1972 National Register nomination gives 10 killed and 22 wounded. Grouard claimed 56 wounded. Charles D. Collins Jr., Atlas of the Sioux Wars, 2nd ed. (Combat Studies Institute, 2006), Map 23; HistoryNet, 'The Battle of Rosebud A to Z'; NPS, National Register nomination, Battle of the Rosebud (1972)

Casualties, killed and wounded (Bourke)57

Crook's aide Lt. John Bourke gave total casualties as 57 and said four of the wounds were mortal. True West Magazine, Battle of the Rosebud

Royall's command (share of Army losses)9 killed, 15 wounded

The staff ride atlas puts about 80 percent of the Army's losses in Royall's companies of the 3rd Cavalry. Charles D. Collins Jr., Atlas of the Sioux Wars, 2nd ed. (Combat Studies Institute, 2006), Map 23

Crow and Shoshone killed and wounded1 killed, 7 wounded (1–5 Crow and 1–8 Shoshone killed in later estimates)

Crook's report gives one Indian scout killed and seven wounded; later estimates run higher. HistoryNet, 'The Battle of Rosebud A to Z'; Kingsley M. Bray, Crazy Horse: A Lakota Life (2006), excerpt; Wikipedia, 'Battle of the Rosebud' (leads only)

Then and now: how the ground has changed

The ridges, coulees and creek of the Rosebud look much as they did in 1876; the state park calls the ground virtually unchanged. Homesteaders and ranchers grazed and plowed much of it, and their hay fields, ranch roads and the Kobold house remain. The park covers only part of the roughly 11,000-acre battlefield.

Weapons

Lakota and Northern Cheyenne warriors

Winchester Model 1866

Winchester Model 1866

Lever-action repeating rifle and carbine · 1866–1898

At Rosebud: The warriors fought with a mix of repeating rifles, single-shot and muzzle-loading guns, bows and lances, charging and falling back across the ridges.

The Henry improved with a loading gate in the side of the receiver and a wooden forend. Widely traded on the Plains, it was among the repeaters carried by Lakota and Cheyenne warriors in the 1870s.

Caliber
.44 Henry rimfire
Capacity
up to 17 rounds
Nickname
"Yellow Boy" for its brass receiver
Photo: Hmaag · CC BY-SA 4.0

Brig. Gen. George Crook's column (2nd and 3rd Cavalry, 4th and 9th Infantry) with Crow and Shoshone allies

Springfield Model 1873 carbine ("Trapdoor")

Springfield Model 1873 carbine ("Trapdoor")

Single-shot breech-loading carbine · 1873–1892

At Rosebud: Crook's troopers carried the Model 1873 Springfield carbine; Royall's companies fought dismounted along the ridge before their dash across the Kollmar ravine.

The U.S. Army's standard carbine after 1873: a hinged breechblock (the "trapdoor") flipped up to load one copper-cased cartridge at a time. Rugged and hard-hitting, but slower than a repeater, and the soft copper cases could stick in a fouled chamber.

Caliber
.45-55 (carbine load)
Effective range
about 300 yd; sighted to 1,200
Rate of fire
about 8–12 rounds a minute
Photo: Trapdoor carbine later owned by Geronimo · Smithsonian (NMAH) · Public domain

Paintings and photographs

The Sioux charging Royall's cavalry
The Sioux charging Royall's cavalry "The Sioux charging Colonel Royall's detachment of Cavalry, June 17th": wood engraving by Charles St. G. Stanley in Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, 12 August 1876. Charles St. G. Stanley, public domain · source
Rosebud Battlefield
Rosebud Battlefield Rosebud Battlefield, "Where the Girl Saved Her Brother", Rosebud County, Montana. National Park Service, public domain · source

★ Medal of Honor 4 recipients

Links go to the official records: the Congressional Medal of Honor Society and, where they exist, the service's own pages.

Free for everyone every year on its anniversary: June 17.

Accuracy score: 62/100 (moderate)

How the accuracy score works

Sources and method

Battle of the Rosebud, 17 June 1876. No U.S. Army staff ride handbook covers this battle. Fixed points: the park headquarters (Kobold homestead) coordinates from Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks, Rosebud Battlefield State Park (Crook's Hill, Conical Hill and Van Vliet's Ridge interpretive sites; NHL 2008; 3,052 acres); the 'The Land Speaks' wayside (HMdb 189806); and the boundary, township and photographs ('view northwest from Crook's Hill to the Conical Hill', 'bend of the Rosebud') of the National Register nomination, Rosebud Battlefield–Where the Girl Saved Her Brother (NPS, 1972). Crook's Hill and Conical Hill are fitted to the labels of the Montana FWP park brochure map, tied to the park entrance and matched to terrain summits (Conical Hill chosen by Kingsley Bray's 'about three-quarters of a mile northwest' of Crook's position); the Kollmar coulee and Royall's ridge follow the terrain west of Crook's Hill and the narrative bearings. Unit lines are fitted to that ground and remain approximate.Course of the battle: 'The Battle of Rosebud A to Z' and 'Memory and the Rosebud' (HistoryNet); Anson Mills's 1917 recollection (in Bruce Brown, 100 Voices from the Little Bighorn); Kingsley M. Bray, Crazy Horse: A Lakota Life (excerpt); Neil C. Mangum, Battle of the Rosebud: Prelude to the Little Bighorn (1987) and J. W. Vaughn, With Crook at the Rosebud (1956), as summarized in True West and The Warrior Trail; Rosebud Battlefield Archaeology Project (2012) and Thomas A. Milter, History and Archaeology of the Rosebud Battlefield (University of Montana MA thesis, 2013); American Battlefield Trust. Medal of Honor: U.S. Army Center of Military History, Indian Wars citations (Snow, Elmer A., Trumpeter, Company M, 3d U.S. Cavalry; Rosebud Creek, 17 June 1876; issued 16 October 1877: 'Bravery in action; was wounded in both arms'); John H. Shingle, First Sergeant, Troop I ('gallantry in action', Victoria Cross Online); Michael A. McGann, First Sergeant, Troop F ('gallantry in action', Victoria Cross Online); Joseph Robinson, First Sergeant, Troop D, in charge of the skirmish line under fire, brought up the lead horses at a critical moment (Medal of Honor Museum); four Medals of Honor for the Rosebud per the American Battlefield Trust. Henry's battalion (Troops B, D, F and L, 3rd Cavalry): Reuben Davenport's 1876 dispatches (Sioux War dispatches, ch. 5). Capt. Azor H. Nickerson, Crook's aide: Arlington Cemetery biography. Strengths and casualties vary widely between sources and are given as ranges. Images from Wikimedia Commons.

Where the positions come from

Further reading