Battlefield Atlas
Plains Wars · 1868 First 3 stages free

Beecher Island, 17-25 September 1868

On 17 September 1868 several hundred Cheyenne, Lakota and Arapaho warriors - Dog Soldiers under Tall Bull, Bull Bear and White Horse, Northern Cheyenne including Roman Nose, Lakota under Pawnee Killer, and Arapaho - attacked Major George A. Forsyth's 50 civilian scouts camped on the Arikaree Fork of the Republican River in eastern Colorado. The scouts held a small sandbar island behind rifle pits for eight days, repelling the first day's mounted charges with Spencer repeating rifles; Roman Nose was mortally wounded leading a charge. Four messengers slipped out on foot to Fort Wallace, and on 25 September Captain Louis Carpenter's Troop H, 10th Cavalry - Buffalo Soldiers - reached the survivors. Forsyth's company lost five killed or mortally wounded and a sixth who died later, with about 15-20 wounded; among the dead was Lieutenant Frederick Beecher, for whom the island was named; Cheyenne sources record nine warriors killed. The fight helped bring on the winter campaign that led to the Washita. The island washed away in the 1935 flood; the battleground park and monument stand on the north bank.

Play the first 3 stages free6 stages on modern satellite imagery and terrain, with 3D elevation

The first 3 of its 6 stages are free to play. The rest opens with Battlefield Explorer ($4.99 a month or $39 a year), which unlocks every battle in the atlas and every one added later. Lifetime access and war packs are one-time options. Free battles include Thermopylae, Plataea, Actium, Viking raid on Lindisfarne, Hastings, Hattin, Agincourt, Vítkov Hill, Kutná Hora, Fall of Constantinople, First St Albans, Lützen, Siege of Buda, Culloden, Fort William Henry, Yorktown, Lake Erie, Waterloo, The Alamo, Monterrey, Antietam, Little Bighorn, Manila Bay, Belleau Wood, Saint-Mihiel, Omaha Beach, Inchon, Ia Drang, Goose Green, 73 Easting, Wanat, Baghdad Thunder Runs, Manbij, Battle of Raqqa, Donetsk Airport, Ilovaisk, Debaltseve, Battle of Kyiv, Battle of Hostomel Airport, Siege of Mariupol, Bilohorivka (Siverskyi Donets crossing), Kharkiv counteroffensive, Kherson counteroffensive, Bakhmut, Vuhledar, Mala Tokmachka and Robotyne, Avdiivka, Kursk incursion.

The Battle of Beecher Island (Zogbaum, 1895)
The Battle of Beecher Island (Zogbaum, 1895) — Rufus F. Zogbaum, Harper's New Monthly Magazine · public domain

The battle, stage by stage

  1. 17 September 1868, dawn

    The horse raid

    Major George A. Forsyth's company of about 50 civilian scouts, recruited at Forts Harker, Hays and Wallace to hunt the war parties raiding western Kansas, has followed a broad trail north and west from Fort Wallace to the Arikaree Fork of the Republican River. On the afternoon of 16 September they camp early in a meadow on the north bank (by most accounts; some say the south), about 200 meters from a low, narrow sandbar island in the nearly dry riverbed. Unknown to them, large Cheyenne, Lakota and Arapaho camps are close by. Just before sunrise a handful of young Cheyenne - about eight, by Cheyenne accounts - rush the picket line waving blankets to stampede the horses. The guards fire, the raiders get away with the four pack mules (by the Army staff ride's account) and a few horses, and the camp is awake. Scout Sharp Grover sees warriors massing on the plain to the west.

  2. 17 September, early morning

    Onto the island

    With hundreds of warriors bearing down, Forsyth orders his men across to the island. They lead their horses through the shallow water, tie them to the willows and young cottonwoods as a barricade, and dig rifle pits in the sand with knives, plates and hands. The island is tiny - about 150 to 250 feet long and 40 feet wide by different accounts - with open riverbed on both sides. Mounted warriors sweep down the valley and around both sides of it, many riding hanging on the far side of their ponies, while others creep through the tall grass on both banks and fire into the pits. The scouts' seven-shot Spencer repeaters break up the charges. Jack Stilwell and two others hold a hole in the grass on the bank at one end of the island (accounts differ, east or west). Forsyth is hit in the thigh, then in the leg; Acting Surgeon John Mooers is shot in the head; all the horses are soon down.

  3. 17 September, about midday

    Roman Nose

    Roman Nose, the famous Northern Cheyenne fighter, has held back: by Cheyenne accounts he believed the protection of his war bonnet broken because he had eaten food taken from a pan with an iron utensil. Taunted for hanging back, he leads the largest charge of the day, formed out of sight up the valley and launched straight at the island's upstream end. Forsyth has his men hold fire until the riders are close, then fire volley after volley. Roman Nose is shot - by most accounts in the back - on the riverbank near the upstream (west) end, according to the Army staff ride and scout Thomas McLoughlin (one Kansas account says the east end); he is carried off and dies that night. The charge breaks around the island. During the day Lieutenant Frederick Beecher, Forsyth's second in command, is mortally wounded, and scouts William Wilson and George Culver are killed. Later charges are weaker; by evening the fight has become a siege.

  4. 17-19 September

    Messengers in the dark

    Fort Wallace is about 75 miles away across open prairie. Around midnight on the first night Forsyth sends Jack Stilwell, a teenage scout, and the older trapper Pierre Trudeau out on foot with a dispatch; they travel by night and hide by day. A second pair, sent the next night, is turned back by the warriors' pickets. On the night of 19 September John Donovan and Allison J. Pliley slip out with Forsyth's second letter: 'I am on a little island and still have plenty of ammunition... The Cheyennes alone number 450, or more.' On the island the scouts deepen the pits, bury their dead in the sand, and the wounded lie untended; sniping goes on but there are no more great charges.

  5. 20-24 September

    Horse meat and prickly pears

    The scouts live on the putrid meat of their dead horses, a coyote and prickly pears. Within a few days the warriors begin to drift away; the camps move off. Both pairs of messengers reach Fort Wallace on 22 September - by one account Donovan and Pliley an hour or so ahead of Stilwell and Trudeau. That night the post commander, Captain Henry C. Bankhead, sends a dispatch to Captain (brevet Lieutenant Colonel) Louis H. Carpenter, camped at Cheyenne Wells with Troop H of the 10th Cavalry, and marches himself with about 100 men of the 5th Infantry and two mountain howitzers; two troops of the 2nd Cavalry under Major James S. Brisbin join him on the way. The courier reaches Carpenter about 10 AM on the 23rd, and he turns north at once. On 24 September his column crosses the trail of a large band moving away from the Arikaree and finds Cheyenne dead on burial scaffolds.

  6. 25 September, about 10 AM

    Carpenter's Buffalo Soldiers

    Early on 25 September Donovan, riding out from Fort Wallace with four men to find the relief, reaches Carpenter's camp. Carpenter rides ahead with about 30 men, an ambulance and supplies and reaches the island about 10 in the morning - the first help in eight days. He finds the warriors gone and Forsyth, by his own story, pretending to read Oliver Twist. Scout Louis Farley dies on the 25th or 26th, after his leg is amputated. Bankhead and Brisbin arrive on the 26th, Stilwell with them, and the survivors, escorted by the 10th Cavalry, reach Fort Wallace on 30 September. Forsyth's company lost five killed or mortally wounded (Beecher, Mooers, Wilson, Culver and Farley); a sixth man died later, and about 15 to 20 were wounded. Records gathered by George Bent and George Bird Grinnell name nine warriors killed (six Cheyenne, one Arapaho, two Lakota); Forsyth claimed 'at least thirty-five' in his letter of 19 September, and later heard 75 from a Brule, according to Brady. The Cheyenne remember it as the fight where Roman Nose was killed. The island itself is gone: a 1935 flood swept away the 1905 monument that stood on it and reshaped the river; the monument's surviving pieces now stand on the north bank.

Forces

About 50 civilian scouts under two officers and a surgeon held the island against several hundred Cheyenne, Lakota and Arapaho warriors, with estimates running from about 200 to 1,000. The scouts and relief columns are well documented; the warriors' numbers are estimates.

Cheyenne Dog Soldiers and Northern Cheyenne (Roman Nose), with Lakota and Arapaho

Warriors presentseveral hundred (about 200-1,000)

Estimates vary widely: the Army's Cheyenne Wars Atlas says 'several hundred'; Heinzman gives 400 to 1,000 and notes others' 400 to 600; the Beecher Island timeline uses about 750; the battle's sources put the full range at about 200 to 1,000. Charles D. Collins Jr., The Cheyenne Wars Atlas (Combat Studies Institute Press, 2010), Maps 18-19; George M. Heinzman, 'Don't Let Them Ride Over Us', American Heritage (1967); Beecher Island timeline and history, Yuma County GenWeb; Maj. James K. Earls III, The Beecher Island Staff Ride and Battlefield Tour (Army University Press, 2019)

Cheyenne (Forsyth's estimate)450 or more

Forsyth's letter of 19 September: 'The Cheyennes alone number 450, or more.' Forsyth's letter of 19 September 1868 and related reports, Yuma County GenWeb

In Roman Nose's charge (one scout's estimate)700-800

Scout McLoughlin's figure; Heinzman calls it probably high. George M. Heinzman, 'Don't Let Them Ride Over Us', American Heritage (1967)

Forsyth's scouts and relief columns (Carpenter's Troop H, 10th Cavalry)

On the islandabout 50 scouts plus 3 officers (50-57 civilians)

Sheridan ordered Forsyth to hire 50 frontiersmen and most accounts give 50 (51 counting Forsyth); the Fort Harker quartermaster listed 57 civilians employed, with Forsyth, Lt. Beecher and Acting Surgeon Mooers as the regulars. Forsyth, Carpenter and Fort Wallace reports, abuffalosoldier.com; Charles D. Collins Jr., The Cheyenne Wars Atlas (Combat Studies Institute Press, 2010), Maps 18-19; John H. Monnett, 'Beecher Island, Battle of', Encyclopedia of the Great Plains (University of Nebraska-Lincoln)

Carpenter's relief (Troop H, 10th Cavalry)2 officers, 69 enlisted men, 17 scouts (about 70-90 in all)

Carpenter's report; another account gives 70 troopers, and his later recollection says some seventy men including about fourteen scouts. Forsyth, Carpenter and Fort Wallace reports, abuffalosoldier.com; 'Rescue at Beecher Island', abuffalosoldier.com; Louis H. Carpenter's recollections, abuffalosoldier.com

Bankhead's relief from Fort Wallaceabout 100 men and two mountain howitzers

The Fort Wallace order sent 100 men and two howitzers (about 100 of the 5th Infantry by the staff ride); two troops of the 2nd Cavalry under Maj. James S. Brisbin joined on the way, strength not given. Forsyth, Carpenter and Fort Wallace reports, abuffalosoldier.com; Maj. James K. Earls III, The Beecher Island Staff Ride and Battlefield Tour (Army University Press, 2019); Louis H. Carpenter's recollections, abuffalosoldier.com

Casualties

Forsyth's company of about 50 lost five killed or mortally wounded, a sixth who died later and about 15 to 20 wounded, roughly a third of its strength. Warrior losses are disputed: Native records name nine dead, while Forsyth claimed at least 35 and a later Lakota report said 75. Certainty: fair.

Cheyenne Dog Soldiers and Northern Cheyenne (Roman Nose), with Lakota and Arapaho

Killed (Cheyenne and Arapaho records)9

Records gathered years later by George Bent and George Bird Grinnell name nine warriors killed (six Cheyenne, two Lakota, one Arapaho), Roman Nose among them; the number wounded is unknown. John H. Monnett, 'Beecher Island, Battle of', Encyclopedia of the Great Plains (University of Nebraska-Lincoln); Charles D. Collins Jr., The Cheyenne Wars Atlas (Combat Studies Institute Press, 2010), Maps 18-19; Maj. James K. Earls III, The Beecher Island Staff Ride and Battlefield Tour (Army University Press, 2019)

Killed (Forsyth's claim)at least 35

Forsyth wrote on 19 September that the scouts had killed 'at least thirty-five' and wounded many more; the Army's Cheyenne Wars Atlas gives his estimate as 35 killed and 100 wounded, and Heinzman says he counted 32 dead. Forsyth's letter of 19 September 1868 and related reports, Yuma County GenWeb; Charles D. Collins Jr., The Cheyenne Wars Atlas (Combat Studies Institute Press, 2010), Maps 18-19; George M. Heinzman, 'Don't Let Them Ride Over Us', American Heritage (1967)

Killed (later Lakota report)75

A Brule Lakota later said 75 were killed, as reported by Cyrus Townsend Brady and Heinzman; some estimates ran to four or five hundred. Heinzman thought the truth lay between Forsyth's count and 75; most modern historians accept the nine named in Native records. George M. Heinzman, 'Don't Let Them Ride Over Us', American Heritage (1967)

Forsyth's scouts and relief columns (Carpenter's Troop H, 10th Cavalry)

Killed or mortally wounded5

Lt. Frederick Beecher, Acting Surgeon John H. Mooers, George W. Culver and William Wilson were killed or mortally wounded on 17-18 September; Louis Farley died on 25 or 26 September after his leg was amputated. John H. Monnett, 'Beecher Island, Battle of', Encyclopedia of the Great Plains (University of Nebraska-Lincoln); Beecher Island timeline and history, Yuma County GenWeb; Forsyth, Carpenter and Fort Wallace reports, abuffalosoldier.com

Relief columnsno losses recorded

Carpenter's and Bankhead's columns arrived after the warriors had gone; the sources consulted record no casualties among them. Louis H. Carpenter's recollections, abuffalosoldier.com

Equipment and ships

Scouts' horses and mulesall lost

The raiders drove off the four pack mules and a few horses at dawn (staff ride); the rest were killed around the island, and Carpenter's report counted 47 dead horses and mules. Maj. James K. Earls III, The Beecher Island Staff Ride and Battlefield Tour (Army University Press, 2019); Forsyth, Carpenter and Fort Wallace reports, abuffalosoldier.com; Louis H. Carpenter's recollections, abuffalosoldier.com

Then and now: how the ground has changed

The island the scouts held no longer exists: a flood in May 1935 changed the Arikaree's channel, destroyed virtually all traces of it and swept away the 1905 monument that stood on it. The surrounding river bottom and prairie are still largely pasture, now the Beecher Island Memorial Association's reunion grounds, with the rebuilt monument on the north bank.

Weapons

Cheyenne Dog Soldiers and Northern Cheyenne (Roman Nose), with Lakota and Arapaho

Plains bow and arrows

Plains bow and arrows

Short composite or self bow · traditional

At Beecher Island: Warriors fought with bows and firearms from the grass on both banks.

Short, powerful bows built for shooting from horseback. Even in the 1870s, when many warriors carried guns, the bow was silent, never ran out of cartridges, and could drop arrows over cover onto men lying behind it.

Length
about 3–4 ft, short for use on horseback
Effective range
about 50–100 yd; lofted farther
Rate
several arrows a minute
Photo: Northern Plains quiver and bow case, collected by Carl Wimar · Public domain

Forsyth's scouts and relief columns (Carpenter's Troop H, 10th Cavalry)

Spencer carbine

Spencer carbine

Lever-action repeating carbine · 1860–1869

At Beecher Island: The scouts' seven-shot Spencer repeaters broke up the mounted charges.

The first widely issued military repeater, loved by Union cavalry late in the Civil War. Thousands passed into civilian and Native hands on the Plains after the war.

Caliber
.56-56 rimfire
Capacity
7 rounds in a tube through the stock
Rate of fire
about 14–20 aimed rounds a minute
Photo: Hmaag · Public domain

Paintings and photographs

The Battle of Beecher Island (Zogbaum, 1895)
The Battle of Beecher Island (Zogbaum, 1895) Forsyth's scouts and Cheyenne warriors fighting at Beecher Island on the Arikaree River, September 1868. Illustration by Rufus F. Zogbaum, Harper's New Monthly Magazine, June 1895. Rufus F. Zogbaum, Harper's New Monthly Magazine · public domain · source

Free for everyone every year on its anniversary: September 17–25.

Accuracy score: 60/100 (moderate)

How the accuracy score works

Sources and method

Battle of Beecher Island (the Arikaree Fight), 17-25 September 1868. No troop map exists and the island no longer exists, so this is a reconstruction. A key source is the U.S. Army's staff ride: Maj. James K. Earls III, The Beecher Island Staff Ride and Battlefield Tour (Army University Press, 2019) - the four pack mules, where Roman Nose was hit, Bankhead's column and the casualty figures. The battleground is placed from the Beecher Island Battlefield Monument (U.S. Geological Survey GNIS) and the Historical Marker Database's 'Buffalo Soldiers to the Rescue' marker at the park; the island from the National Register of Historic Places nomination for the Beecher Island Battleground (1976), which records that the 1935 flood destroyed virtually all traces of the island and that the monument was re-erected on the north side, and from the report that the 1905 monument stood about 200 yards south of the present one (Legends of America). Events follow Forsyth's dispatch of 19 September 1868 and Carpenter's report and letter (Yuma County GenWeb; abuffalosoldier.com; Carpenter's recollections); John H. Monnett, 'Beecher Island, Battle of', Encyclopedia of the Great Plains (University of Nebraska), and his The Battle of Beecher Island and the Indian War of 1867-1869 (University Press of Colorado); George Bird Grinnell, The Fighting Cheyennes (1915); George M. Heinzman, 'Don't Let Them Ride Over Us', American Heritage (1967); Fred Chiaventone, 'Looking death in the face', The Past; Kansas Historical Society, Kansapedia; the 1912 Kansas Cyclopedia; the 1905 souvenir history (cogenweb); and the Beecher Island timeline. Accounts differ on which bank the scouts camped on (north in Hurst, Freeman and Ziegler, and the staff ride's stand 2, used here; south in Cyrus Townsend Brady's 1904 account and the National Register form), the end of the island Jack Stilwell held, the size of the island, the number of warriors (estimates run from about 200 to 1,000), the time of Roman Nose's charge and the end of the island where he fell. The river's course is drawn schematically; warrior positions, courier routes and the relief routes are approximate.

Where the positions come from

Further reading