Battlefield Atlas
Iraq War · 2005 First 3 stages free

Tal Afar, 2005

From May to September 2005 the 3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment (Col. H. R. McMaster), with Iraqi Army, police and attached U.S. units, fought to wrest Tal Afar in north-western Iraq from al-Qaeda in Iraq and allied insurgents. Months of raids and cordons by the 2nd ('Saber') Squadron, chiefly in the old quarter of Sarai and in Qadisiyah, culminated in Operation RESTORING RIGHTS in early September: the city was ringed by a berm, civilians were evacuated from Sarai, and a combined U.S.-Iraqi force cleared it, after which some thirty joint outposts held the city. The campaign became a much-studied example of counterinsurgency. Figures differ by source and period. For the 2–6 September fighting the coalition briefing of 13 September counted 118 insurgents killed and 137 captured, three to six civilians killed, 11 Americans wounded (one killed elsewhere in the west of the city) and 8 Iraqi soldiers killed and 19 wounded. For the whole deployment to February 2006 Herrera's Army study gives more than 150 insurgents killed and about 600 detained; 2nd Squadron lost 8 troopers and 12 attached soldiers, with 59 Purple Hearts; Iraqi soldiers lost 38 killed and 15 wounded and the police 6 killed and 24 wounded. FPRI reports the regiment lost 21 soldiers in northwestern Iraq.

Play the first 3 stages free8 stages on modern satellite imagery and terrain, with 3D elevation

The first 3 of its 8 stages are free to play. The rest opens with Battlefield Explorer ($4.99 a month or $39 a year), which unlocks every battle in the atlas and every one added later. Lifetime access and war packs are one-time options. Free battles include Thermopylae, Plataea, Actium, Viking raid on Lindisfarne, Hastings, Hattin, Agincourt, Vítkov Hill, Kutná Hora, Fall of Constantinople, First St Albans, Lützen, Siege of Buda, Culloden, Fort William Henry, Yorktown, Lake Erie, Waterloo, The Alamo, Monterrey, Antietam, Little Bighorn, Manila Bay, Belleau Wood, Saint-Mihiel, Omaha Beach, Inchon, Ia Drang, Goose Green, 73 Easting, Wanat, Baghdad Thunder Runs, Manbij, Battle of Raqqa, Donetsk Airport, Ilovaisk, Debaltseve, Battle of Kyiv, Battle of Hostomel Airport, Siege of Mariupol, Bilohorivka (Siverskyi Donets crossing), Kharkiv counteroffensive, Kherson counteroffensive, Bakhmut, Vuhledar, Mala Tokmachka and Robotyne, Avdiivka, Kursk incursion.

Patrol in Tal Afar, 11 September 2005
Patrol in Tal Afar, 11 September 2005 — PO1 Alan D. Monyelle, U.S. Navy · public domain

The battle, stage by stage

  1. 1–5 May 2005

    Saber Squadron takes over

    Tal Afar, a mostly Turkmen city of perhaps 150,000–200,000 about 50 miles west of Mosul, had been retaken in September 2004 and then left lightly held; by spring 2005 insurgents, al-Qaeda in Iraq 'Takfiri' fighters alongside Sunni nationalist 'Resistance' groups, controlled much of it through intimidation and murder. On 1 May the 3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment's 2nd Squadron (LTC Christopher Hickey), based at FOB Sykes on the airfield south-west of the city, assumed full responsibility for Tal Afar and began Operation COLD FUSION. On 3 May G Troop, searching for roadside bombs in the old quarter of Sarai, south-east of the castle, was spotted and drawn into a fight of more than four hours in which six Iraqi soldiers were wounded; Herrera records that the insurgents used women and children as shields. Returning on 5 May to search a mosque, the troop fought for more than three hours with AH-64D Apaches of the regiment's 4th Squadron overhead; 12 insurgents were killed. Positions inside Sarai are approximate throughout.

  2. 20–26 May 2005

    COLD STEEL and Hassan Qoi

    On 20 May Operation COLD STEEL cordoned the Qadisiyah neighborhood in the north of the city, which Herrera calls the insurgents' battleground. Three days later a suicide car bomb killed 15 members of the Jolaq tribe and wounded 30. On 26 May insurgents tried to overrun an Iraqi Army patrol base in Hassan Qoi and were beaten off; Herrera credits the Iraqi soldiers, with tank and sniper support. The cordon line is drawn schematically.

  3. 4–14 June 2005

    The Sarai raid

    On 4 June McMaster and Hickey met about 80 sheikhs at the Iraqi Army post at al-Kisik. On 7 June, acting on an informant's information, the squadron raided Sarai for 30 high-value targets, detaining 23 and killing about 20 insurgents, by Herrera's account. LTC Terrence K. Crowe of the 98th Advisory Support Team (10th Battalion, 98th Regiment, 98th Division), leading Iraqi soldiers, was mortally wounded when they were ambushed in an alley. SFC Gary Villalobos, F Troop's mortar section sergeant, kept the mission going after the ambush, returned fire, called for armor, threw a grenade onto an enemy position and recovered LTC Crowe's body to an arriving Bradley; his Silver Star citation says he was 'never leaving a fallen comrade behind'. It was presented in October 2011. On 14 June in Qadisiyah, E Troop's Pfc. Marcus Waggoner earned a Bronze Star for Valor dragging his wounded squad leader out of heavy fire (DVIDS). Exact positions are not recorded; blocks are approximate.

  4. 9–30 July 2005

    SABER UNLEASHED

    Shaping operations, SABER UNLEASHED, ran from 1 July to 31 August. At 5:20 AM on 9 July a G Troop raid into Sarai to look for surface-to-air missiles, with Special Forces, Iraqi partners and two 4th Squadron troops, grew into a squadron-level fight. During the casualty evacuation at 5:40 the M113 ambulance carrying the wounded Spc. Hoby Bradfield struck a roadside bomb, which destroyed it, killed a medic and wounded another; Bradfield was pronounced dead at the 228th Combat Support Hospital in Mosul. The raid ended with six detainees. G Troop's SSgt. Rigoberto Torres and Pfc. Christopher Davis received Bronze Stars for Valor for pulling casualties from the wreck and covering the medevac (DVIDS). On 30 July a squadron raid on about a dozen targets in Qadisiyah captured 24 insurgents. In July, too, work began on a berm around the city to funnel traffic through checkpoints; Herrera gives it 12 km.

  5. 7 August 2005

    The southeastern woods

    Herrera's account has a reconnaissance of the woods on the city's southeastern edge, where insurgents cached supplies, opening with a 65-round artillery barrage. Troopers uncovered caches and killed, captured or wounded insurgents; the woods were then declared off-limits and a free-fire zone. The woods' extent and the battery's position are not recorded and are drawn schematically. By the end of August, Herrera counts more than 130 insurgents killed and more than 200 captured.

  6. 2 September 2005

    RESTORING RIGHTS: the zone reconnaissance

    Operation RESTORING RIGHTS began with a three-day zone reconnaissance. Herrera counts well over 3,000 U.S. soldiers and 5,500 Iraqi soldiers and police (the coalition briefing of 13 September said about 3,500, rising to about 3,800, Americans and over 5,000 Iraqis), with the 4th Police Commando Brigade (the 'Wolf Brigade'), a Kurdish Peshmerga battalion, 2-325 Infantry of the 82nd Airborne and special operations forces. 2nd Squadron was the main effort: E Troop, H Company and two Iraqi battalions worked south into Sarai while F and G Troops, A Company of the 113th Engineers and three Iraqi battalions came north. The berm sealed the east, 1st Squadron (LTC Gregory Reilly) and the 3rd Brigade, 3rd Iraqi Division took the western half of the city, special operations forces blocked westward at the castle, and a route south was left open. McMaster told the Long War Journal (5 September 2005) the idea was 'to trap them in Sarai or force them toward our checkpoints to the south'. Resistance was heavy in the south and light in the north. Peshmerga and Wolf Brigade positions are not recorded and are not drawn.

  7. 4 September 2005

    The fight for Sarai

    Resistance stiffened in Sarai, where insurgents had booby-trapped houses. The troops cleared house by house with tank, Bradley, TOW, Apache Hellfire and machine-gun fire in support, R Troop of the 4th Squadron among the aviation, the helicopters at times firing within 50–75 meters of friendly troops, until they reached Phase Lines (routes) BELL AIR and BARRACUDA (named on Herrera's map; not drawn here). By the end of the day the force was preparing to evacuate Sarai. The DoD briefing put the heaviest fighting between 2 and 6 September. That day Capt. Christopher A. Molino of the 3rd Battalion, 75th Ranger Regiment, ground force commander of a joint special operations task force in Tal Afar, earned the Silver Star under small-arms and grenade fire, his citation crediting him with helping save wounded Rangers.

  8. 5–14 September 2005

    Evacuation, assault and handover

    The civilian evacuation of Sarai, planned for three days, lasted about a week on the orders of Prime Minister Ibrahim al-Jaafari; some insurgents tried to slip out disguised as women and families. The squadron ran a center outside the berm that fed and sheltered more than 1,500 displaced people (site not recorded; drawn schematically). When the final assault went in, no shots were fired and no insurgents were found. On 14 September Sarai and Hassan Qoi were handed over to LTC Christopher Gibson's 2-325 Infantry. The coalition's 13 September briefing counted, for 2–6 September, 118 insurgents killed and 137 captured and three to six civilians killed; 11 U.S. troopers wounded, with one killed elsewhere in the western part of the city; and 8 Iraqi soldiers killed and 19 wounded. The insurgents' withdrawal route is approximate.

Forces

For Operation RESTORING RIGHTS the coalition massed about 3,000–3,800 U.S. soldiers and 5,000–5,500 Iraqi soldiers and police, plus a Peshmerga battalion; through the summer the city was held mainly by one cavalry squadron. Insurgent strength was never reliably counted.

Insurgents (al-Qaeda in Iraq and allied groups)

Fightersunknown

None of the sources used gives an overall estimate; the Long War Journal reported that shaping operations had cut the insurgent presence to less than half before the September offensive. Bill Roggio, 'Operation Restoring Rights in Tal Afar', Long War Journal, 5 Sep 2005

3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment and Iraqi forces

U.S. soldiers (RESTORING RIGHTS)about 3,000–3,800 (3,000–3,800)

Herrera gives well over 3,000; the coalition's 13 September briefing said about 3,500, rising to about 3,800; FPRI gives 3,800 and GlobalSecurity 3,500. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006); DoD press briefing with Col. H. R. McMaster, 13 Sep 2005 (GlobalSecurity transcript); Mackubin T. Owens, 'Counterinsurgency from the Bottom Up' (FPRI, 2017)

Iraqi soldiers and police (RESTORING RIGHTS)about 5,000–5,500 (5,000–5,500)

Herrera gives 5,500 Iraqi soldiers and police; the 13 September briefing said over 5,000 Iraqi security forces; GlobalSecurity says about 5,000 from the Iraqi 3rd Division. Iraqi forces included the 3rd Iraqi Division and the 4th Police Commando Brigade ('Wolf Brigade'). Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006); DoD press briefing with Col. H. R. McMaster, 13 Sep 2005 (GlobalSecurity transcript); GlobalSecurity, 'Operation Restoring Rights'

Kurdish Peshmerga1 infantry battalion

Provided by Multi-National Corps–Iraq for RESTORING RIGHTS (Herrera); its strength is not given. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006)

Armor (per ground squadron)41 M1A2 tanks and 41 M3A2 Bradleys

Herrera's figure for each of the regiment's three ground squadrons; two squadrons (1st and 2nd) fought in the city. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006)

Casualties

Figures differ by period. For 2–6 September the coalition's 13 September briefing counted 118 insurgents killed and 137 captured, 3–6 civilians killed, 11 Americans wounded and one killed, and 8 Iraqi soldiers killed and 19 wounded. For the whole deployment to February 2006 Herrera gives over 150 insurgents killed and about 600 detained, 8 troopers and 12 attached soldiers of 2nd Squadron killed, and 38 Iraqi soldiers and 6 police killed; FPRI reports 21 of the regiment's soldiers killed in northwestern Iraq. Certainty: fair.

Insurgents (al-Qaeda in Iraq and allied groups)

Killed (2–6 September)118 (coalition count)

Col. H. R. McMaster's 13 September 2005 briefing counted 118 insurgents killed between 2 and 6 September; early press reporting (Long War Journal, 5 September) spoke of over 200 killed in three days. Coalition figures; no independent count exists. DoD press briefing with Col. H. R. McMaster, 13 Sep 2005 (GlobalSecurity transcript); Bill Roggio, 'Operation Restoring Rights in Tal Afar', Long War Journal, 5 Sep 2005

Captured (2–6 September)137 (coalition count)

Same briefing; GlobalSecurity's operation summary cites 341 people detained by 13 September. DoD press briefing with Col. H. R. McMaster, 13 Sep 2005 (GlobalSecurity transcript); GlobalSecurity, 'Operation Restoring Rights'

Killed and captured (26 August–13 September)141 killed, 211 captured

Army News Service, counting Iraqi and coalition results since 26 August, with at least 119 suspects detained since 10 September. Army News Service, 'Operation Restoring Rights to secure Tal Afar', 13 Sep 2005 (GlobalSecurity)

Killed and detained (whole deployment, to February 2006)more than 150 killed, about 600 detained

Herrera's Army study gives the regiment's totals for the whole deployment to February 2006 as over 150 killed and some 600 detained, noting that some detainees were later released for lack of evidence or after false accusations. The counts cover different periods and do not reconcile; they should not be added together. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006)

3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment and Iraqi forces

Killed (2nd Squadron, 3rd ACR, deployment to February 2006)8

Herrera: the squadron lost 8 troopers over the whole deployment to February 2006. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006)

Killed (attached soldiers, deployment to February 2006)12

Herrera counts 12 soldiers attached to or serving alongside 2nd Squadron killed over the deployment to February 2006. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006)

Killed (3rd ACR, whole regiment)21

Mackubin Owens's FPRI case study reports that the regiment lost 21 soldiers in northwestern Iraq. For 2–6 September the coalition's 13 September briefing reported 11 U.S. troopers wounded, with one killed elsewhere in the western part of the city. Mackubin T. Owens, 'Counterinsurgency from the Bottom Up' (FPRI, 2017); DoD press briefing with Col. H. R. McMaster, 13 Sep 2005 (GlobalSecurity transcript)

Wounded (2nd Squadron, deployment to February 2006)59 Purple Hearts

Herrera records 59 Purple Hearts for 2nd Squadron over the deployment; for 2–6 September the 13 September briefing reported 11 U.S. troopers wounded. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006)

Killed (Iraqi forces)38 soldiers and 6 police

Over the deployment to February 2006 Herrera gives 38 Iraqi soldiers killed and 15 wounded, and 6 Tal Afar policemen killed and 24 wounded. For 2–6 September the coalition's 13 September briefing counted 8 Iraqi soldiers killed and 19 wounded. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006); DoD press briefing with Col. H. R. McMaster, 13 Sep 2005 (GlobalSecurity transcript)

Civilians

Killed (2–6 September)3–6 (coalition count)

The coalition's 13 September briefing said three to six civilians were killed in the 2–6 September fighting, depending on where the casualties occurred; no independent count was found. DoD press briefing with Col. H. R. McMaster, 13 Sep 2005 (GlobalSecurity transcript)

Killed and wounded (Jolaq car bomb, 23 May)15 killed, 30 wounded

Herrera records a suicide car bomb that killed 15 members of the Jolaq tribe and wounded 30. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006)

Displaced (sheltered by the regiment)more than 1,500

The Support Squadron's center for displaced residents outside the berm fed and sheltered over 1,500 people during the week-long evacuation of Sarai (Herrera). The total number who left their homes is not recorded. Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute, 2006)

Then and now: how the ground has changed

The street plan and the castle hill of 2005 are still there, but the Islamic State's 2014–2017 occupation and the 2017 battle to retake the city left the Ottoman citadel largely demolished and more than a thousand buildings damaged, so much of the city seen in 2005 has been damaged, cleared or rebuilt.

Weapons

Insurgents (al-Qaeda in Iraq and allied groups)

AK-47 / Type 56

AK-47 / Type 56

Assault rifle · 1949–present

At Tal Afar: The insurgents fought from booby-trapped houses in Sarai with Kalashnikov-pattern rifles, roadside bombs and snipers.

Mikhail Kalashnikov's AK-47 became the world's most widespread military rifle thanks to its simplicity and reliability in mud, heat and rain. North Vietnamese and Viet Cong troops carried both Soviet AKs and the Chinese-made copy, the Type 56.

Caliber
7.62×39mm
Rate of fire
about 600 rounds/min
Magazine
30-round box
Effective range
about 350 m
Photo: U.S. Department of Defense · Public domain

3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment and Iraqi forces

M1A1 Abrams

M1A1 Abrams

Main battle tank · 1985–present

At Tal Afar: The 3rd ACR's tanks and Bradleys worked the wider streets while troopers and Iraqi infantry cleared Sarai's alleys on foot.

The U.S. Army and Marine Corps main battle tank. In 1991 its thermal sights and 120 mm gun let crews kill Iraqi tanks at ranges the enemy could not answer, often through rain, smoke and sandstorms; in 2003 its armor proved almost impervious to the RPGs and older Iraqi guns it met, which made armored raids like the Thunder Runs possible.

Gun
120 mm smoothbore
Crew
4
Weight
about 57–63 t
Photo: U.S. Air Force photo · public domain
AH-64A Apache

AH-64A Apache

Attack helicopter · 1986–present

At Tal Afar: 4th Squadron's Apaches supported the troops, at times firing within 50–75 m of them in Sarai.

The Army's attack helicopter, built to kill tanks at night. In 1991 Apache battalions struck Iraqi armor ahead of the ground divisions, including the Medina Division's positions on 27 February.

Armament
30 mm chain gun, Hellfire missiles, rockets
Crew
2
Sensors
night-vision and thermal targeting
Photo: NARA · public domain

Paintings and photographs

Patrol in Tal Afar, 11 September 2005
Patrol in Tal Afar, 11 September 2005 U.S. Army and Iraqi soldiers cross an intersection on a security patrol in downtown Tal Afar, 11 September 2005. Exact spot not recorded; pinned downtown, approximate. PO1 Alan D. Monyelle, U.S. Navy · public domain · source
Searching for insurgents
Searching for insurgents Soldiers of the 3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment on a security mission in Tal Afar, 13 September 2005, as the regiment and Iraqi forces search for insurgents and weapons caches. Place not recorded; pinned at Sarai, approximate. PO1 Alan D. Monyelle, U.S. Navy · public domain · source
Tal Afar castle
Tal Afar castle The Ottoman-era castle at the center of Tal Afar, about 2006; special operations forces held a blocking position here in September 2005. Unknown author (Wikimedia Commons) · public domain · source

Free for everyone every year on its anniversary: September 2–14.

Accuracy score: 60/100 (moderate)

How the accuracy score works

Sources and method

Tal Afar, May–September 2005. No U.S. Army staff ride handbook was found. Key source: Ricardo A. Herrera, 'Brave Rifles at Tall 'Afar, September 2005', in In Contact! Case Studies from the Long War, Vol. I (Combat Studies Institute Press, 2006), with Map 10 (timeline, units, maneuver plan, casualties). Further: Multi-National Force Iraq / DoD press briefing with Col. H. R. McMaster, 13 September 2005; Army News Service, 'Operation Restoring Rights to secure Tal Afar'; GlobalSecurity, Operation Restoring Rights; Mackubin T. Owens, 'Counterinsurgency from the Bottom Up' (FPRI case study, 2017); Bill Roggio, Long War Journal, 'Operation Restoring Rights in Tal Afar' (5 Sep 2005) and 'Tal Afar: Calm Before the Storm in Sarai' (7 Sep 2005); McCone, Scott and Mastroianni, U.S. Air Force Academy study (2008); LTC Terrence K. Crowe (Military Times, Honor the Fallen); valor: Silver Star citations of SFC Gary Villalobos (Military Times) and Capt. Christopher A. Molino (Military Times), and DVIDS, 25 Nov 2005. FOB Sykes (Tall Afar Army Airfield) from NGA GeoNames; Sarai from the gazetteer locality 'Al Saray' (Mapcarta). Castle, mosque, hospital and neighborhood label points from OpenStreetMap; neighborhood extents, the Sarai block and all positions inside it are reconstructions from Herrera's text and Map 10 and are approximate.

Where the positions come from

Further reading