Battlefield Atlas
War of 1812 · 1813 Free to explore

Battle of Lake Erie (Put-in-Bay), 10 September 1813

On 10 September 1813 Master Commandant Oliver Hazard Perry's nine-vessel U.S. squadron sailed from Put-in-Bay on South Bass Island and met Commander Robert Heriot Barclay's six British vessels in western Lake Erie, roughly 7 to 10 miles west to north-west of the bay. Barclay, short of men and supplies, carried more long guns (about 63 guns in all against Perry's 54), while Perry relied on carronades that needed close range. A wind shift at about 10 AM gave the Americans the weather gauge. Perry's flagship Lawrence engaged Barclay's Detroit and Queen Charlotte almost alone for two hours while Lt. Jesse Elliott's Niagara hung back, and was wrecked. Perry then rowed to Niagara, took her through the British line as Detroit and Queen Charlotte fouled each other, and a few minutes after 3 PM the whole British squadron surrendered. The victory gave the United States control of Lake Erie, forced the British to abandon Amherstburg and Detroit, and led to Harrison's victory at the Thames. Congress voted gold medals to Perry and Elliott on 6 January 1814; the quarrel over Elliott's conduct lasted for decades. The battle position rests on National Park Service distance statements and Perry's 'off the West Sister'; island positions are from USGS and Canadian name records; ship positions follow the recorded engagements and are schematic.

Open the interactive map8 stages on modern satellite imagery and terrain, with 3D elevation

This battle is free to explore — no account needed.

Perry's Victory on Lake Erie (Birch, c. 1814)
Perry's Victory on Lake Erie (Birch, c. 1814) — Thomas Birch, Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts · CC0

The battle, stage by stage

  1. 10 September 1813, dawn to about 7 AM

    Perry leaves Put-in-Bay

    Since August Master Commandant Oliver Hazard Perry's squadron, built at Erie, Pennsylvania, had been based at Put-in-Bay on South Bass Island, cutting the lake route that supplied the British army and its Native allies at Amherstburg (Fort Malden). Short of food and stores, Commander Robert Heriot Barclay sailed from Amherstburg on 9 September to force a battle. At first light a lookout sighted his six vessels to the north-west, beyond Rattlesnake Island. Perry signaled his nine vessels to get under way; the squadron sailed at about 7 AM. The American vessels are shown at anchor in the bay at first light (anchorage layout schematic); Barclay's position here is conjectural.

  2. About 10-11 AM

    Into the open lake

    The wind was light and from the south-west, favoring the British. For more than two hours Perry tacked between Rattlesnake and South Bass islands trying to get to windward; by one account he then decided to run to leeward of Rattlesnake and fight with the wind against him. At about 10 AM the wind shifted to the south-east, giving the Americans the weather gauge. Barclay formed line heading south-west to west (Chippawa, Detroit, Hunter, Queen Charlotte, Lady Prevost, Little Belt) and waited. Perry put Lawrence opposite Detroit and Niagara opposite Queen Charlotte, and hoisted his 'Don't Give Up the Ship' battle flag.

  3. 11:45 AM-12:15 PM

    Detroit opens fire

    At 11:45 AM Detroit fired the first shot at long range, about 1 to 1.5 miles (accounts differ); a second 24-pounder ball struck Lawrence. Perry's brigs were armed mostly with carronades, heavy at short range but out-ranged by Barclay's long guns, so he had to close. In the light wind the American line came down at an angle of about 15 degrees to the British line, with Scorpion and Ariel on Lawrence's weather bow firing their long guns, while the four smallest gunboats lagged about two miles astern. Lawrence took about half an hour to get within carronade range, suffering on the way.

  4. 12:15-2:30 PM

    Lawrence fights alone

    From about 12:15 Lawrence fought Detroit at close range, about 250 yards. Behind her Lt. Jesse Elliott held Niagara back behind the slow Caledonia, out of carronade range and firing only her long guns; he later said he was keeping his station in the line. Queen Charlotte, unable to reach Niagara, moved up past Hunter and joined Detroit and Hunter in firing on Lawrence. By 2:30 PM Lawrence was a wreck, her guns on the engaged side dismounted, and about four of every five men fit for duty were killed or wounded (22 killed and 61 wounded by the return NHHC cites; other counts differ slightly). The British also suffered: Queen Charlotte's captain, Robert Finnis, was killed and Barclay was badly wounded.

  5. About 2:30-2:45 PM

    Perry's row to Niagara

    As the wind freshened, Niagara finally came up on the windward side. Perry took four unwounded seamen and his young brother into Lawrence's first cutter and rowed for Niagara, nearly half a mile away, by Lossing's account a row of about fifteen minutes under fire, carrying his battle flag. He took command of Niagara and sent Elliott in the boat to bring up the gunboats. Soon after Perry left, Lt. John Yarnall, with only a few men able to stand, struck Lawrence's colors. Boat position and track are schematic.

  6. About 2:45-3 PM

    Niagara breaks the line

    Perry signaled close action and bore down in the nearly undamaged Niagara. Barclay's ships, their senior officers killed or wounded, tried to wear (turn) to bring fresh broadsides to bear; Detroit fell aboard Queen Charlotte and the two ships fouled. Niagara passed through the British line, firing her starboard guns into Detroit, Queen Charlotte and Hunter at close range and her port guns into the smaller vessels; which ones differs by account (Perry: 'a large schooner and sloop', that is Lady Prevost and Little Belt; Lossing: Lady Prevost and Chippawa). Lady Prevost, by Lossing's account, had already drifted out of the line after losing her rudder. The gunboats, brought up by Elliott, raked from astern. Exact positions in the melee are schematic.

  7. About 3-4 PM

    "We have met the enemy and they are ours"

    A few minutes after 3 PM Detroit, Queen Charlotte, Hunter and Lady Prevost struck one after another. Chippawa and Little Belt tried to escape and were caught, Chippawa by Trippe and Little Belt by Scorpion, Little Belt about three miles off. An entire British squadron had surrendered, according to the NPS something that had never happened in British naval history. Perry returned to Lawrence to receive the surrender and wrote in pencil to Maj. Gen. William Henry Harrison: 'We have met the enemy and they are ours: Two Ships, two Brigs, one Schooner & one Sloop.' His report to the Navy Secretary was headed 'off the West Sister', 4 PM; the NPS says the battle ended near West Sister Island. Losses (official returns): American 27 killed, 96 wounded; British 41 killed, 94 wounded, with about 300 captured.

  8. 11-12 September 1813

    Back to Put-in-Bay

    That night the dead seamen were buried in the lake. On 11 September the squadron and its prizes sailed back into Put-in-Bay, and on 11 or 12 September (accounts differ) three American officers (Lt. John Brooks, Midshipmen Henry Laub and John Clark) and three British (Capt. Robert Finnis, Lt. John Garland, Lt. James Garden) were buried together on the shore of South Bass Island; in 1913 their remains were reinterred beneath the memorial column. Control of Lake Erie let Perry carry Harrison's army to Canada; the British abandoned Amherstburg and Detroit, and on 5 October Harrison defeated Procter and Tecumseh at the Thames. Anchorage positions are schematic.

Forces

Nine American vessels with 54 guns and about 530 men against six British vessels with 63 guns and about 440–500 men. Barclay had more long guns; Perry's carronades threw roughly twice the British broadside at close range. Ship and gun counts are firm; British crew totals are uncertain.

British squadron (Barclay)

Vessels and guns6 vessels, 63 guns

Two ships (Detroit, Queen Charlotte), a brig, two schooners and a sloop (NPS; NHHC table). Roosevelt gives a broadside of 459 lb, mostly from long guns. National Park Service, 'The Battle of Lake Erie'; Naval History and Heritage Command, 'Battle of Lake Erie' (archived), Perry's returns; Theodore Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812 (1882), Project Gutenberg

Menabout 440 (440–502)

Roosevelt settles on about 440 (possibly too low); the NHHC table gives 502, a figure Roosevelt says has no traceable source; the American Battlefield Trust gives 450. Theodore Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812 (1882), Project Gutenberg; Naval History and Heritage Command, 'Battle of Lake Erie' (archived), Perry's returns; American Battlefield Trust, 'Lake Erie'

Crewsnot more than 50 British seamen

Barclay wrote that the rest were 'a mixed crew of Canadians, and soldiers'; NPS names the Royal Newfoundland Fencibles and regulars of the 41st Regiment of Foot. Barclay to Sir James Yeo, 12 September 1813 (Windsor Public Library); National Park Service, 'The Battle of Lake Erie'

U.S. squadron (Perry)

Vessels and guns9 vessels, 54 guns

Three brigs, five schooners and a sloop (NPS). Roosevelt gives a broadside of 936 lb, mostly from carronades; the Erie Maritime Museum puts the American broadside at about 150 percent of the British. The schooner Ohio was away for supplies. National Park Service, 'The Battle of Lake Erie'; Theodore Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812 (1882), Project Gutenberg; Erie Maritime Museum / Flagship Niagara League, 'Battle of Lake Erie'

Men532 (490–540)

532 on the prize-money list (NHHC table, Roosevelt, Erie Maritime Museum); Perry's own roll gave 490 (Roosevelt) and the American Battlefield Trust gives 540. Perry reported 116 men unfit for duty on the day. Naval History and Heritage Command, 'Battle of Lake Erie' (archived), Perry's returns; Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812, excerpted by History Moments: 'Composition of the opposing fleets'; Erie Maritime Museum / Flagship Niagara League, 'Battle of Lake Erie'; American Battlefield Trust, 'Lake Erie'

Soldiers and militia aboardmore than 250

NPS: over 150 militiamen and about 100 infantry volunteers from Harrison's army; Roosevelt counts 158 marines or soldiers and 45 volunteers. National Park Service, 'The Battle of Lake Erie'; Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812, excerpted by History Moments: 'Composition of the opposing fleets'

Casualties

The Americans lost 27 killed and 96 wounded, most of them in Lawrence; the British lost 41 killed and 92–94 wounded, and the rest of their roughly 300 surviving men were captured with all six vessels. The figures come from the commanders' returns and are well established; sources differ only by a few wounded. Certainty: good.

British squadron (Barclay)

Killed41

Barclay's return gives 41 killed, as cited by Roosevelt and the NHHC; NPS, the American Battlefield Trust and The Canadian Encyclopedia agree (one NHHC exhibit page says 40). Among the dead was Queen Charlotte's captain, Robert Finnis. Theodore Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812 (1882), Project Gutenberg; Naval History and Heritage Command, 'Battle of Lake Erie' (archived), Perry's returns; National Park Service, Perry's Victory park brochure (1986); American Battlefield Trust, 'Lake Erie'; The Canadian Encyclopedia, 'Battle of Lake Erie (Battle of Put-in-Bay)'

Wounded94 (92–94)

Barclay's return gives 94 wounded (Roosevelt, NHHC, The Canadian Encyclopedia); the 1986 NPS park brochure gives 92 and the American Battlefield Trust 93. Barclay himself was severely wounded, and every officer commanding a vessel and every second-in-command was killed or wounded. Theodore Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812 (1882), Project Gutenberg; Naval History and Heritage Command, 'Battle of Lake Erie' (archived), Perry's returns; The Canadian Encyclopedia, 'Battle of Lake Erie (Battle of Put-in-Bay)'; National Park Service, Perry's Victory park brochure (1986); American Battlefield Trust, 'Lake Erie'; Barclay to Sir James Yeo, 12 September 1813 (Windsor Public Library)

Capturedabout 306 (about 300–306)

The American Battlefield Trust and The Canadian Encyclopedia give 306 captured, besides the killed and wounded; the Erie Maritime Museum puts total British losses, captured included, at about 440. American Battlefield Trust, 'Lake Erie'; The Canadian Encyclopedia, 'Battle of Lake Erie (Battle of Put-in-Bay)'; Erie Maritime Museum / Flagship Niagara League, 'Battle of Lake Erie'

U.S. squadron (Perry)

Lawrence (flagship)22 killed, 61 wounded (61–66 wounded)

Perry's return as printed by the NHHC and Roosevelt gives 22 killed and 61 wounded, and the names on the NPS memorial wall follow it; the Erie Maritime Museum gives 22 killed and 66 wounded, about 80 percent of the men fit for duty. The NHHC text puts it as 83 of a crew of 103 fit men; NPS says four of every five. Naval History and Heritage Command, 'Battle of Lake Erie' (archived), Perry's returns; Theodore Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812 (1882), Project Gutenberg; National Park Service, 'Killed and Wounded in Battle of Lake Erie' (memorial rotunda wall); Erie Maritime Museum / Flagship Niagara League, 'Battle of Lake Erie'; National Park Service, 'The Battle of Lake Erie'

Rest of the squadron5 killed, 35 wounded

Perry's return: Niagara 2 killed and 25 wounded; Ariel 1 and 3; Scorpion 2 killed; Caledonia 3, Somers 2 and Trippe 2 wounded; Porcupine and Tigress none. Naval History and Heritage Command, 'Battle of Lake Erie' (archived), Perry's returns; Theodore Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812 (1882), Project Gutenberg

Equipment and ships

British vesselsall 6 captured

Detroit, Queen Charlotte, General Hunter and Lady Prevost struck; Chippawa and Little Belt tried to escape and were taken, Chippawa by Trippe and Little Belt by Scorpion. According to the NPS, it was the first time an entire British squadron had surrendered. National Park Service, 'The Battle of Lake Erie'; The Canadian Encyclopedia, 'Battle of Lake Erie (Battle of Put-in-Bay)'

American vesselsnone lost

Lawrence was left a wreck and struck her colors after Perry left her, but no American vessel was lost. National Park Service, 'The Battle of Lake Erie'; Naval History and Heritage Command, 'Battle of Lake Erie' (art exhibit)

Then and now: how the ground has changed

The battle was fought on open water some 7–10 miles west to north-west of Put-in-Bay, and nothing of it is visible on the lake today; the islands keep their 1813 shapes, but Put-in-Bay is now a resort village and Perry's 352-foot memorial column, built 1912–15, stands over the bay.

Weapons

British squadron (Barclay)

Royal Navy ship's gun

Royal Navy ship's gun

Naval artillery · 1700s-1850s

At Lake Erie: Barclay's squadron carried more long guns (about 63 guns in all against Perry's 54) and opened the action at long range.

Smoothbore cast-iron guns mounted in rows along a warship's decks were the backbone of British sea power. Besides solid shot, crews could fire heated shot and incendiary carcasses to set targets on fire. In coastal campaigns, guns were often landed from ships to arm shore batteries.

Shot
Iron balls, commonly 6 to 32 lb by ship size
Mounting
Wooden truck carriage on a gun deck
Crew
Several men per gun
Photo: Moshi Anahory · CC BY-SA 2.0

U.S. squadron (Perry)

Carronade

Carronade

Short-barrelled naval gun · 1770s–1850s

At Lake Erie: Perry relied on carronades that needed close range; Lawrence fought Detroit at about 250 yards.

A short, light, large-bore gun first made by the Carron Company in Scotland. It threw a heavy ball at close range with a small crew, earning the nickname 'the smasher'. As Victory passed astern of Bucentaure, her 68-pounder carronade, loaded with a round shot and a keg of 500 musket balls, raked the French flagship through her stern windows.

Shot
up to 68 lb (Victory's forecastle pair)
Range
short, a few hundred yards at most
Crew
far fewer men than a long gun of the same shot weight
Photo: Carronade · Rama · CC BY-SA 3.0 fr
Royal Navy ship's gun

Royal Navy ship's gun

Naval artillery · 1700s-1850s

At Lake Erie: Ariel's four long 12-pounders and Scorpion's long gun led the American line.

Smoothbore cast-iron guns mounted in rows along a warship's decks were the backbone of British sea power. Besides solid shot, crews could fire heated shot and incendiary carcasses to set targets on fire. In coastal campaigns, guns were often landed from ships to arm shore batteries.

Shot
Iron balls, commonly 6 to 32 lb by ship size
Mounting
Wooden truck carriage on a gun deck
Crew
Several men per gun
Photo: Moshi Anahory · CC BY-SA 2.0

Paintings and photographs

Perry's Victory on Lake Erie (Birch, c. 1814)
Perry's Victory on Lake Erie (Birch, c. 1814) Oliver Hazard Perry's victory on Lake Erie, 10 September 1813. Oil painting by Thomas Birch, about 1814, at the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts. Thomas Birch, Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts · CC0 · source
Battle of Lake Erie (Powell, 1873)
Battle of Lake Erie (Powell, 1873) Perry is rowed from the Lawrence to the Niagara during the battle. William Henry Powell's 1873 version of his Perry's Victory, in the U.S. Senate collection. William Henry Powell, U.S. Senate Collection · public domain · source

Free for everyone every year on its anniversary: September 10.

Accuracy score: 70/100 (good)

How the accuracy score works

Sources and method

Battle of Lake Erie (Put-in-Bay), 10 September 1813. No U.S. Army or Navy staff ride handbook was found for this battle. Park authority: National Park Service, Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial: The Battle of Lake Erie, Battle of Lake Erie, page 2, page 3 and the park brochure (1986); observation-deck panels (HMdb 280063) and the NPS panel at HMdb 58544 (opening range about a mile); NPS, 'We Have Met the Enemy' (part 4) and the memorial (burial of the officers); Gibraltar Island marker (HMdb 46785). Naval History and Heritage Command: Battle of Lake Erie (Perry's report to Secretary Jones, 'off the West Sister', 4 PM, and casualty returns) and 1813 on the Lakes: Lake Erie. British: Barclay's letter to Sir James Yeo, 12 September 1813 (Windsor Public Library). Contemporary American: Samuel R. Brown, Views on Lake Erie (1814), American Battlefield Trust primary source. Histories: Theodore Roosevelt, The Naval War of 1812 (1882), Project Gutenberg text (Lake Erie; captures of Chippawa and Little Belt); lines of battle as excerpted by History Moments; U.S. Naval Institute Proceedings, September 1913; Benson J. Lossing, Pictorial Field-Book of the War of 1812, ch. 25; Erie Maritime Museum / Flagship Niagara League (route out of the islands); The Canadian Encyclopedia; National Trust for Historic Preservation. Medals: Resolution of 6 January 1814, 3 Stat. 141. Coordinates: USGS GNIS (Put-in-Bay, West Sister, Middle Bass, North Bass, Sugar Island, The Rattles), FAA (Rattlesnake Island), Natural Resources Canada (Middle Sister Island). The battle position is placed from distance statements (7-10 miles W to NW of the monument) and is uncertain by several km; Barclay's dawn position, the drift, the escape course of Chippawa and Little Belt and all ship spacing are schematic.

Where the positions come from

Further reading