Battlefield Atlas
Texas Revolution · 1836 First 3 stages free

Coleto Creek and Goliad, 19–27 March 1836

In March 1836, after the fall of the Alamo, Colonel James W. Fannin's Texian command at Presidio La Bahía (Goliad) was ordered to fall back to Victoria. Leaving late, on 19 March, it was overtaken on the open prairie near Coleto Creek by General José de Urrea's Mexican army. In a hollow square the Texians beat off attacks until dark, but without water, cover or a way out, and facing artillery the next morning, they surrendered on 20 March. Marched back to Goliad, they were held at the presidio until Palm Sunday, 27 March, when on Santa Anna's orders about 342 prisoners, by the Handbook of Texas count, were shot. About 28 escaped and others were spared, some through the intervention of Francita Alavez and Mexican officers. 'Remember Goliad!' became, with the Alamo, the Texian battle cry at San Jacinto.

Play the first 3 stages free8 stages on modern satellite imagery and terrain, with 3D elevation

The first 3 of its 8 stages are free to play. The rest opens with Battlefield Explorer ($4.99 a month or $39 a year), which unlocks every battle in the atlas and every one added later. Lifetime access and war packs are one-time options. Free battles include Thermopylae, Plataea, Actium, Viking raid on Lindisfarne, Hastings, Hattin, Agincourt, Vítkov Hill, Kutná Hora, Fall of Constantinople, First St Albans, Lützen, Siege of Buda, Culloden, Fort William Henry, Yorktown, Lake Erie, Waterloo, The Alamo, Monterrey, Antietam, Little Bighorn, Manila Bay, Belleau Wood, Saint-Mihiel, Omaha Beach, Inchon, Ia Drang, Goose Green, 73 Easting, Wanat, Baghdad Thunder Runs, Manbij, Battle of Raqqa, Donetsk Airport, Ilovaisk, Debaltseve, Battle of Kyiv, Battle of Hostomel Airport, Siege of Mariupol, Bilohorivka (Siverskyi Donets crossing), Kharkiv counteroffensive, Kherson counteroffensive, Bakhmut, Vuhledar, Mala Tokmachka and Robotyne, Avdiivka, Kursk incursion.

Presidio La Bahía
Presidio La Bahía — Robert Tripp — CC BY-SA 4.0

The battle, stage by stage

  1. 19 March 1836, morning

    Leaving Fort Defiance

    Ordered by Sam Houston to fall back on Victoria after the Alamo fell, Colonel James W. Fannin delays for days while detachments under Amon King and William Ward are lost at Refugio. On the morning of 19 March, under a heavy fog, he finally marches out of Presidio La Bahía — which his men call Fort Defiance — with roughly 300 to 400 men (counts differ), nine guns and ox-carts, leaving the fort's buildings burning. General José de Urrea's Mexican force is reportedly about two hours behind. An hour is lost at the San Antonio River crossing recovering a gun from a broken cart.

  2. 19 March, about 1–1:30 PM

    Caught on the open prairie

    Fannin halts again to rest and graze oxen that had not been fed the day before, losing his lead. On the open prairie east of Manahuila Creek, Mexican cavalry come out of the timber behind the column. Fannin presses for the timber ahead (Perdido Creek, under a mile; Coleto, 1–2 miles), or at least higher ground 400–500 yards off, turning obliquely off the road, but an ammunition cart breaks down. The cavalry ride around the column, cutting off Albert Horton's mounted advance, which withdraws toward Victoria. Urrea's infantry — about 260 men, after he sent 100 back to Goliad, with some 80 cavalry — close up from the western timber. About 9–10 miles from Goliad, without water or cover, Fannin forms for battle.

  3. 19 March, about 1:30 PM to sunset

    The hollow square

    The Texians form an oblong hollow square three ranks deep with guns at the corners, its front facing north to north-west: by Hobart Huson's reconstruction and the Handbook of Texas, the San Antonio Grays and Red Rovers (at the east end) on the front, Westover's regulars on the left (west), the Mobile Grays on the right (east) and Duval's Mustangs and the Refugio men on the rear (south); Fannin commands from the rear of the right face. Urrea attacks from all sides — riflemen under Morales from the western timber on the left, Urrea himself with grenadiers and the San Luis battalion on the right, Salas's column on the front and Núñez's cavalry on the rear (about 260 infantry and 80 cavalry engaged). Canister and rifle fire repulse repeated charges; Fannin is wounded. By sunset, accounts give 7 to 10 Texians killed and some 50 to 70 wounded; Mexican losses, unrecorded, were reportedly heavy. Tradition, preserved by survivor William Hunter's rock pile and the 1916 obelisk, places the square at the monument; its exact outline is not known.

  4. Night of 19 March and dawn, 20 March

    Night, and the guns arrive

    The night is cold and drizzly. There is no water for the men, the wounded or the guns, whose crews cannot sponge them. Fannin proposes breaking out to the Coleto timber in the dark, but the men reportedly vote to stay with the wounded. They dig a ditch and pile carts and dead animals as a breastwork while Mexican pickets keep up fire. At about 6:30 AM Urrea's reinforcements and ammunition arrive from Goliad with artillery — two 4-pounders and a howitzer with about 100 infantry by Huson's account, 400 to 500 men by other counts. The Mexican guns open fire from about 160 paces, by Urrea's account (their exact position is approximate).

  5. 20 March, morning

    Surrender

    Fannin's officers judge further resistance hopeless. After a parley the Texians surrender — about 230 to 240 unwounded men and some 50 wounded. They believed they had agreed terms: prisoner-of-war treatment, care for the wounded and parole to the United States. But by Santa Anna's orders and a congressional decree Urrea could accept only unconditional surrender, offering to intercede with Santa Anna; the surviving capitulation, signed by Fannin, Benjamin Wallace and Joseph Chadwick, surrenders them 'subject to the disposition of the supreme government'. Fannin apparently did not make this clear to his men. The able-bodied prisoners are marched back to Goliad that day; the wounded follow over the next days.

  6. 20–26 March 1836

    Prisoners at La Bahía

    The prisoners are crowded into the presidio, many of them in its chapel. They are joined by men of William Ward's Georgia Battalion taken after Refugio, and by William Miller's Nashville Battalion, captured unarmed on landing at Copano. Urrea, marching on toward Victoria, leaves Colonel José Nicolás de la Portilla (a lieutenant colonel in some accounts) in command at Goliad and writes urging clemency. Santa Anna, enforcing the Tornel decree that treated armed foreign volunteers as pirates, orders the prisoners executed. Portilla receives the order on 26 March and decides to obey it.

  7. Palm Sunday, 27 March 1836

    Palm Sunday

    Early in the morning the prisoners are marched out in three columns, between files of soldiers, on the Béxar, Victoria and San Patricio roads, and halted within about a mile of the fort, where they are shot. The wounded and Colonel Fannin are killed inside the presidio. A man-by-man study gives 342 dead, Fannin among them (Handbook of Texas); other counts run from about 350 to over 400. About 28 men escape — 24 from the two columns on the river roads, many by swimming the San Antonio River, and 4 from the San Patricio road — among them Herman Ehrenberg, whose column had turned off the Victoria road toward the river. Others are spared: surgeons, mechanics and interpreters, Miller's men, and men hidden or saved through the efforts of Francita Alavez, remembered as the 'Angel of Goliad', and of officers such as Colonel Francisco Garay. The places where the columns halted are not marked; positions here are conjectural.

  8. 3 June 1836

    Remember Goliad

    The bodies were partly burned and left in the open. After San Jacinto, General Thomas J. Rusk's army gathers the remains and buries them with military honors on 3 June 1836, at the place now marked by the Fannin Memorial Monument, dedicated in 1938. Together with the Alamo, the killing at Goliad gave the Texian army its cry at San Jacinto: 'Remember the Alamo! Remember Goliad!'

Forces

Fannin marched out of Goliad with roughly 300–400 men and nine guns and was caught by about 260 Mexican infantry and 80 cavalry (Urrea had set out with about 360 infantry), reinforced with artillery on the morning of 20 March. Both sides' numbers vary by source, and survivors' accounts run far higher for the Mexican force.

Mexican Army (Urrea; Col. Portilla at Goliad)

Engaged at Coleto, 19 Marchabout 340 (340–440)

The Handbook of Texas and the American Battlefield Trust give about 260 infantry and 80 cavalry engaged on 19 March; Urrea had set out with about 360 infantry, the figure in Mexican accounts. Survivor John C. Duval's estimate of about 1,000 cavalry plus several hundred infantry is far higher. Handbook of Texas Online (TSHA), 'Coleto, Battle of'; American Battlefield Trust, 'Goliad Executions on March 27, 1836' (Battle of Coleto Creek and Goliad Massacre); Wikipedia, 'Battle of Coleto' (lead only); John C. Duval, Early Times in Texas (account reproduced by Sons of DeWitt Colony Texas)

Reinforcements, morning of 20 Marchabout 100 infantry and 3 guns, or 400–500 men (100–500)

Hobart Huson and William C. Davis (via Wikipedia) give about 100 infantry with two 4-pounders and a howitzer; the American Battlefield Trust gives 400–500 men; Duval gave 750 cavalry and an artillery company. Hobart Huson, Refugio (Battle of Coleto, as reproduced by Sons of DeWitt Colony Texas); American Battlefield Trust, 'Goliad Executions on March 27, 1836' (Battle of Coleto Creek and Goliad Massacre); Wikipedia, 'Goliad Campaign' (lead only; cites Davis, Three Roads to the Alamo, 2006, p. 237)

Texian forces (Fannin)

Present, leaving Goliad 19 Marchabout 300–400 (250–450)

The American Battlefield Trust gives 300; the Texas Parks and Wildlife site booklet about 350; the THC Coleto marker about 400; Wikipedia's infobox 450 (uncited); Duval about 250 plus an artillery company and some 25 mounted men. American Battlefield Trust, 'Goliad Executions on March 27, 1836' (Battle of Coleto Creek and Goliad Massacre); Texas Parks and Wildlife Department, Fannin Battleground State Historic Site (2006, archived by UNT); Texas Historical Commission Atlas, 'Battle of Coleto and Goliad Massacre' marker (1974); John C. Duval, Early Times in Texas (account reproduced by Sons of DeWitt Colony Texas)

Guns9

Nine guns, as given in Urrea's account (quoted by Huson) and in Wikipedia's summary. Hobart Huson, Refugio (Battle of Coleto, as reproduced by Sons of DeWitt Colony Texas); Wikipedia, 'Battle of Coleto' (lead only)

Casualties

The fight at Coleto cost the Texians about 7–10 killed and 50–70 wounded and the Mexican army an unrecorded number, estimated at 200–400; about 230–240 unwounded and some 50 wounded Texians surrendered. A week later 342 prisoners by a man-by-man count (other counts about 350 to over 400) were shot at Goliad, about 28 escaped and some 95 were spared. Texian figures are fairly well documented but still disputed; Mexican losses are estimates. Certainty: fair.

Mexican Army (Urrea; Col. Portilla at Goliad)

Killed and wounded at Coleto, 19–20 March (combined)unknown; perhaps about 200 (about 200–400)

No Mexican casualty return is given in the sources consulted. The American Battlefield Trust says only that Urrea 'had sustained high casualties'; H. W. Brands (Lone Star Nation, 2005) estimates about 200; the Texian surgeon Joseph H. Barnard, as quoted by survivor John C. Duval, put Mexican killed and wounded at 300–400. American Battlefield Trust, 'Goliad Executions on March 27, 1836' (Battle of Coleto Creek and Goliad Massacre); John C. Duval, Early Times in Texas (account reproduced by Sons of DeWitt Colony Texas); Wikipedia, 'Goliad Campaign' (lead only; cites H. W. Brands, Lone Star Nation, 2005, p. 392)

Texian forces (Fannin)

Killed at Coleto, 19 March7–10 (7–10)

The American Battlefield Trust and the Texas Parks and Wildlife site booklet give seven dead by nightfall (Dr. Barnard's count); Hobart Huson gives about ten killed with several more mortally wounded; Brands gives nine and Duval ten. American Battlefield Trust, 'Goliad Executions on March 27, 1836' (Battle of Coleto Creek and Goliad Massacre); Texas Parks and Wildlife Department, Fannin Battleground State Historic Site (2006, archived by UNT); Hobart Huson, Refugio (Battle of Coleto, as reproduced by Sons of DeWitt Colony Texas); John C. Duval, Early Times in Texas (account reproduced by Sons of DeWitt Colony Texas)

Wounded at Coleto, 19 Marchabout 50–70 (50–70)

The American Battlefield Trust gives 50 wounded by the end of the first day, Fannin among them; the Handbook of Texas (via Wikipedia) and Barnard give about 60; Huson gives 60–70 badly wounded and many more slightly; Duval about 70. American Battlefield Trust, 'Goliad Executions on March 27, 1836' (Battle of Coleto Creek and Goliad Massacre); Hobart Huson, Refugio (Battle of Coleto, as reproduced by Sons of DeWitt Colony Texas); Wikipedia, 'Battle of Coleto' (lead only; cites the Handbook of Texas)

Captured, 20 Marchabout 230–240 unwounded and some 50 wounded

The Handbook of Texas gives about 230–240 unwounded and some 50 wounded prisoners taken at the surrender. Handbook of Texas Online (TSHA), 'Coleto, Battle of'

Prisoners executed at Goliad, 27 March342 (342–445)

Includes Ward's and other men captured elsewhere, not only Fannin's command. A man-by-man study gives 342 executed, Fannin among them; other counts run from about 350 (American Battlefield Trust, 'upwards of 350'; World History Encyclopedia 350–400) and 'approximately 400' (THC grave marker) to 425–445 (Handbook of Texas entry by Davenport and Roell). Handbook of Texas Online (TSHA), 'Goliad Massacre' (Davenport and Roell); Texas Historical Commission marker, Presidio La Bahía (HMdb 36230); American Battlefield Trust, 'Goliad Executions on March 27, 1836' (Battle of Coleto Creek and Goliad Massacre); Joshua J. Mark, 'Goliad Massacre', World History Encyclopedia; Texas Historical Commission Atlas, 'Grave of Colonel J. W. Fannin and His Men' marker; EBSCO Research Starters, 'Goliad Massacre'

Escaped the executionsabout 28 (25–30)

The American Battlefield Trust and World History Encyclopedia give 28; the THC grave marker says approximately 30; Duval says 25 or 30 reached the Brazos settlements. American Battlefield Trust, 'Goliad Executions on March 27, 1836' (Battle of Coleto Creek and Goliad Massacre); Joshua J. Mark, 'Goliad Massacre', World History Encyclopedia; Texas Historical Commission Atlas, 'Grave of Colonel J. W. Fannin and His Men' marker

Then and now: how the ground has changed

The Coleto field is still open rural country, but the Texians' trenches are long gone, a 14-acre memorial park with an obelisk, a bandstand and landscaped grounds marks the surrender site, and the railroad town of Fannin, US 59 and, since 1980, Coleto Creek Reservoir have grown up nearby. At Goliad the presidio, a ruin from 1837 to 1963, was rebuilt in 1963–67.

Weapons

Mexican Army (Urrea; Col. Portilla at Goliad)

India Pattern "Brown Bess" musket

India Pattern "Brown Bess" musket

Flintlock smoothbore musket · 1797-1850s

At Coleto Creek and Goliad: Urrea's infantry carried the same British-made muskets as the army at the Alamo; his riflemen under Morales worked in from the western timber.

First made for the British East India Company, the India Pattern was a simpler, shorter Brown Bess that Britain adopted as its standard infantry musket during the French wars. It was produced in huge numbers, and surplus guns were supplied to allies and later sold abroad, including to Mexico. Rugged but inaccurate, it was meant for massed volleys at close range.

Caliber
.75 in
Barrel
39 in (990 mm)
Effective range
About 100 yards
Rate of fire
2-3 rounds per minute
Photo: Smithsonian Institution (NMAH) · Public domain
Napoleonic cavalry lance

Napoleonic cavalry lance

Polearm (cavalry) · c. 1800-1910s

At Coleto Creek and Goliad: Urrea's cavalry rode around Fannin's column on the open prairie and closed the rear of the square.

Polish lancers revived the lance in western Europe, and their success led France to convert several regiments into chevau-legers lanciers from 1811; Prussia, Austria and Russia fielded uhlans of their own. The long reach let a lancer strike swordsmen before they could reach him and stab infantry who had lost their formation. It was deadly in pursuit and fearsome against broken units.

Length
About 9 ft (2.7-2.9 m)
Use
Out-reaching swordsmen and spearing infantry or fallen men
Photo: Metropolitan Museum of Art · CC0

Texian forces (Fannin)

American long rifle

American long rifle

Rifled flintlock (Pennsylvania / "Kentucky" rifle) · about 1730–1840

At Coleto Creek and Goliad: Fannin's volunteers fought from a hollow square three ranks deep on open prairie, with no water and little cover.

Made by German-American gunsmiths in Pennsylvania for hunting on the frontier. The spiral rifling and a greased patch around the ball made it far more accurate than a musket, but slow to load and too delicate for a bayonet, so riflemen fought as skirmishers and sharpshooters rather than in the line.

Caliber
typically .45–.54
Effective range
200–300 yd in skilled hands
Rate of fire
about 1 round a minute
Photo: Long rifle of William Clark · Missouri Historical Society · Public domain

Paintings and photographs

Presidio La Bahía
Presidio La Bahía Presidio La Bahía (Fort Defiance), Goliad, restored 1963–67. Robert Tripp — CC BY-SA 4.0 · source
James W. Fannin
James W. Fannin Col. James Walker Fannin Jr. Unknown artist — public domain · source
José de Urrea
José de Urrea General José de Urrea. Sergio Zaragoza Sicre — CC BY-SA 2.0 · source
Fannin Memorial Monument
Fannin Memorial Monument Fannin Memorial Monument, over the grave of Fannin and his men. Michaelluckey — CC BY 4.0 · source

Free for everyone every year on its anniversary: March 19–27.

Accuracy score: 58/100 (limited)

How the accuracy score works

Sources and method

Coleto Creek and Goliad, 19–27 March 1836. No U.S. Army staff ride handbook covers this campaign. Fixed points come from the Historical Marker Database (hmdb.org) and Texas Historical Commission markers: the 1916 Fannin Battleground Memorial obelisk (HMdb 234638), which the Texas Historical Commission says marks the spot where Fannin surrendered, and the rock pile left by survivor William L. Hunter (HMdb 192256); the THC marker 'Battle of Coleto and Goliad Massacre' (HMdb 116301); Presidio La Bahía (HMdb 36230, 235071); the grave of Fannin and his men and the Fannin Memorial Monument (HMdb 35516, 237668, 235075); the Angel of Goliad marker (HMdb 36263); Mission Espíritu Santo (HMdb 68955); and the 1817 El Perdido marker (HMdb 131944). The march, fight and executions follow the Texas State Historical Association's Handbook of Texas — 'Coleto, Battle of', 'Goliad Massacre' and 'Goliad Campaign of 1836' — the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department's Fannin Battleground State Historic Site (2006) for the march, and Hobart Huson's reconstruction in Refugio (as reproduced by Sons of DeWitt Colony) with the Handbook for the facing and order of the square and the Mexican attacks; strengths, casualties and the executions follow the American Battlefield Trust (article; Herman Ehrenberg's account), Joshua J. Mark, 'Goliad Massacre' (World History Encyclopedia, 2025, after Hardin, Texian Iliad, and Davis, Three Roads to the Alamo), Harbert Davenport, Notes from an Unfinished Study of Fannin and His Men (TSHA, ed. Maxey, 2002), and Jay A. Stout, Slaughter at Goliad (Naval Institute Press, 2008). The position of the square at the obelisk is traditional; metal-detector surveys (SWCA for the THC, Galindo and Miller, 2011; Houston Archeological Society, 2014) documented musket-ball scatters but no revised position has been published. The route from Goliad, the size of the square, the Mexican positions and the places where the three columns were shot on 27 March are approximate or conjectural. Images from Wikimedia Commons.

Where the positions come from

Further reading