Battlefield Atlas
Korean War · 1951 First 3 stages free

Heartbreak Ridge, 13 September – 15 October 1951

From 13 September to 15 October 1951, while armistice talks were suspended, the U.S. 2nd Infantry Division fought for a seven-mile hill mass north of the Punchbowl in eastern Korea, just west of the ground taken at Bloody Ridge. The narrow ridge, with Hills 894, 931 and 851 along its crest, was held by the North Korean 6th, 12th and 13th Divisions in deep bunkers. A month of frontal attacks by the 23rd Infantry and its attached French Battalion, with the 9th Infantry on Hill 894, won and lost Hill 931 repeatedly; the French alone had 157 casualties before October, by a U.S. Military Academy study of the division's records. In October the new division commander, Maj. Gen. Robert N. Young, widened the attack in Operation Touchdown: all three regiments attacked at once while engineers built a road for the 72nd Tank Battalion up the Mundung-ni valley, cutting off the ridge from behind. Hill 931 fell on 6 October and the French took Hill 851 on 13 October. The official history counts over 3,800 casualties in the 2nd Division and estimates close to 25,000 North Korean and Chinese losses. Two Medal of Honor actions are shown on the map, both posthumous awards: Pfc. Herbert K. Pililaau (17 September) and Sfc. Tony K. Burris (8–9 October).

Play the first 3 stages free8 stages on modern satellite imagery and terrain, with 3D elevation

The first 3 of its 8 stages are free to play. The rest opens with Battlefield Explorer ($4.99 a month or $39 a year), which unlocks every battle in the atlas and every one added later. Lifetime access and war packs are one-time options. Free battles include Thermopylae, Plataea, Actium, Viking raid on Lindisfarne, Hastings, Hattin, Agincourt, Vítkov Hill, Kutná Hora, Fall of Constantinople, First St Albans, Lützen, Siege of Buda, Culloden, Fort William Henry, Yorktown, Lake Erie, Waterloo, The Alamo, Monterrey, Antietam, Little Bighorn, Manila Bay, Belleau Wood, Saint-Mihiel, Omaha Beach, Inchon, Ia Drang, Goose Green, 73 Easting, Wanat, Baghdad Thunder Runs, Manbij, Battle of Raqqa, Donetsk Airport, Ilovaisk, Debaltseve, Battle of Kyiv, Battle of Hostomel Airport, Siege of Mariupol, Bilohorivka (Siverskyi Donets crossing), Kharkiv counteroffensive, Kherson counteroffensive, Bakhmut, Vuhledar, Mala Tokmachka and Robotyne, Avdiivka, Kursk incursion.

Heartbreak Ridge seen from the north
Heartbreak Ridge seen from the north — U.S. Army Signal Corps (National Archives 111-SC-382926), public domain

The battle, stage by stage

  1. 13 September 1951

    Into the Sat'ae-ri valley

    Fresh from Bloody Ridge, the U.S. 2nd Infantry Division is ordered to take the next hill mass north: a long, narrow ridge running north and south between the Mundung-ni valley on the west and the Sat'ae-ri valley on the east, crowned from south to north by Hills 894, 931 and 851 (heights in meters on the U.S. maps). By the official history, 'some members of the staff contemplated that the enemy response would be less vigorous', and Brig. Gen. Thomas E. de Shazo, commanding the division, committed a single regiment. After a 30-minute artillery preparation from 5:30 a.m., Col. James Y. Adams's 23rd Infantry moves north from Hill 702 and across the Sat'ae-ri valley, Lt. Col. Virgil E. Craven's 3rd Battalion leading and Lt. Col. Henry F. Daniels's 2nd Battalion behind, aiming to cut the ridge between Hills 931 and 851. Concealed bunkers of the North Korean 1st Regiment, 6th Division, on the approach spur stop them at its foot by nightfall. The French Battalion relieves the 38th Infantry on Hill 868, a little over two miles east of Hill 931.

  2. 14–16 September

    Hill 894

    On 14 September the division redirects Col. John M. Lynch's 9th Infantry against Hill 894, the southern end of the ridge, with Company B of the 72nd Tank Battalion in support. The 9th's 2nd Battalion takes the hill on 15 September and then holds it against repeated counterattacks. The 23rd Infantry, dug in short of its objective, attacks Hill 931 on 16 September and in the days that follow, but the attacks stall against a deep bunker system. The North Korean 13th Regiment replaces the battered 1st. The unit blocks on this map are placed from the official history's descriptions, not from a surveyed map.

  3. 17–27 September

    Back and forth on Hill 931

    The fight for Hill 931 becomes a grinding exchange of bunkers and crests. On 17 September, near Pia-ri, Pfc. Herbert K. Pililaau of Company C, 23rd Infantry, volunteers to stay behind and cover his platoon's withdrawal when its ammunition runs low; by his Medal of Honor citation he fires his automatic weapon, throws his grenades, and fights on with a trench knife and his fists until he is killed, and more than 40 enemy dead are later counted where he fought. On 23 September elements of the 1st Battalion under Maj. George H. Williams Jr. briefly win the crest before a counterattack by a company of the North Korean 3rd Regiment, 12th Division, drives them off. On 26 September the French push south along the ridge and are thrown back by the North Korean 15th Regiment, and regimental tanks fire on bunkers from the Sat'ae-ri valley. Supplies come up the exposed Pia-ri valley; carrying a litter down could take up to ten hours. On 27 September the division and corps commanders halt the attacks. The new division commander, Maj. Gen. Robert N. Young, later called this phase a 'fiasco' and put about 85 percent of the casualties down to enemy mortars. Away to the southwest, the 1st Battalion, 9th Infantry, clears the crest of Hill 1024 on 25 September (its position here is approximate). Pililaau's marker is placed approximately on the southwest slope of Hill 931, toward the Pia-ri valley.

  4. 28 September – 5 October

    Planning Operation Touchdown

    Young widens the battle. Operation Touchdown, planned largely by Maj. Thomas W. Mellon and issued on 2 October, sends all three regiments forward at once: the 9th Infantry against the hills west of the Mundung-ni valley, the 23rd against Hill 931 and the ridge west of it, and the 38th Infantry, with the Netherlands Battalion attached, toward Hill 485 and then in support of the 72nd Tank Battalion. Lt. Col. Robert W. Love's 2nd Engineer Combat Battalion begins blasting and grading a tank road up the cratered, mined Mundung-ni valley. Task Force Sturman, formed on 3 October, raids the Sat'ae-ri valley with tanks on 4 October; the same day the 38th finds Hill 485 abandoned. Units rehearse on sand tables; the 23rd's 2nd Battalion, which will attack Hill 931 from the south, is shown here on the southern end of the ridge (an inference from the plan, not a stated position). On the evening of 5 October Marine Corsairs strike the North Korean lines.

  5. 5–6 October

    Hill 931 at night

    Touchdown opens on the night of 5 October. Daniels's 2nd Battalion climbs Hill 931 from the south with no artillery preparation, to keep surprise, while the 37th Field Artillery fires counter-mortar missions; Craven's 3rd Battalion follows in reserve. The French feint south toward Hill 931 from the north. By 3 a.m. on 6 October the two battalions hold the southern half of the hill; after beating off a counterattack, and clearing bunkers with flamethrowers and grenades, the 23rd holds all of Hill 931 by late morning. To the west the 38th Infantry takes Hill 728 on 6 October, while the 9th Infantry closes on Hill 867, about three miles southwest of Hill 894 on the far side of the Mundung-ni valley.

  6. 7–9 October

    The western spurs

    While the 1st Battalion and the French begin working north along the crest toward Hill 851, the 9th and 38th Infantry take the spurs west of the Mundung-ni valley that guard the tank road: the 9th's 3rd Battalion has won the crest of Hill 867 by 7 October, the 38th seizes Hill 636 on 7 October and moves on Hill 605, and the 9th takes Hills 960 and 666, to the northwest and north of Hill 867, on 8 October. In the vicinity of Mundung-ni on 8 and 9 October, Sfc. Tony K. Burris of Company L, 38th Infantry, charges enemy positions alone and, though twice wounded, keeps leading the assault, exposing himself to locate a machine gun and destroying positions with grenades until he is mortally wounded. He received the Medal of Honor posthumously. His citation says his comrades then secured Hill 605; the official history ties the 38th's seizure of Hill 605 to the tank advance of 10 October, and the map follows the citation. The positions of the western hills on this map are schematic.

  7. 10 October

    Tanks to Mundung-ni

    On 10 October the engineers finish the road and the Shermans of Lt. Col. John O. Woods's 72nd Tank Battalion, with Company L of the 38th Infantry and an engineer platoon, race up the valley to the town of Mundung-ni and beyond, shooting up bunkers and cutting the supply and relief routes that fed the defenders of the western slopes of Heartbreak. The Chinese 204th Division, 68th Army, coming in to relieve the North Korean V Corps, is caught in the open. The same afternoon Company G, 2nd Battalion, 23rd Infantry, led by its executive officer Lt. Raymond W. Riddle, takes Hill 520, a hump at the western end of a spur from the ridge a little over a mile south of Mundung-ni, with Company E firing in support from a parallel ridge 500 yards to the south.

  8. 11–15 October

    Hill 851

    Hill 851, the needle-like northern peak, is held by the North Korean 23rd Regiment, 13th Division, with the 21st and 19th Regiments in support. From 10 to 12 October the 23rd's 1st Battalion and the French fight north 'bunker by bunker' while Craven's 3rd Battalion presses in from the west along the spur from Hill 520. At daybreak on 13 October the French Battalion storms the peak, ending the fight for Heartbreak Ridge. The 38th Infantry takes Hill 974 on 12 October and Hill 1220 on 15 October, closing Operation Touchdown. The official history gives the 2nd Division over 3,800 casualties from 13 September to 15 October (Gugeler's editor says over 3,700), almost half of them in the 23rd Infantry and the French Battalion; the division estimated North Korean and Chinese losses at close to 25,000.

Forces

A reinforced U.S. infantry division (three regiments, French and Dutch battalions, a tank battalion and five-plus artillery battalions) attacked parts of three North Korean divisions, later joined by a Chinese division. No published source gives a total for either side; the North Korean regiments were badly understrength by October.

North Korean People's Army (later Chinese People's Volunteers)

Formations engagedparts of 3 KPA divisions, then a CPV division

KPA 6th Division (1st, 13th, 15th Regiments), 12th Division (3rd Regiment) and 13th Division (19th, 21st, 23rd Regiments) of the V Corps sector, with the Chinese 204th Division, 68th Army, arriving to relieve them in October (Hermes). W. G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (CMH, 1966), pp. 90–96, as cited in Wikipedia, 'Battle of Heartbreak Ridge' (leads)

Total strengthunknown

No figure is published; Hermes says the 6th and 12th Divisions were far understrength by the eve of Touchdown and that none of the 3rd, 1st or 15th Regiments had a thousand men. W. G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (CMH, 1966), p. 94, as cited in Wikipedia, 'Battle of Heartbreak Ridge' (leads)

U.S. 2nd Infantry Division, with the French Battalion and the attached Netherlands Battalion

Formations engaged1 reinforced infantry division

The 9th, 23rd and 38th Infantry, the French Battalion (with the 23rd) and the Netherlands Battalion (with the 38th), the 72nd Tank Battalion and 2nd Engineer Combat Battalion; no total headcount is published. W. G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (CMH, 1966), pp. 89–93, as cited in Wikipedia, 'Battle of Heartbreak Ridge' (leads); ROK Ministry of Patriots and Veterans Affairs, Key Battles: Heartbreak Ridge

Tanks68 Shermans (72nd Tank Battalion)

The West Point thesis, citing S. Freedman, 'Tankers at Heartbreak' (Armor, 1952), for the October tank thrust. U.S. Military Academy thesis, 'Fire and Maneuver: The 2nd Infantry Division's Assault on Korea's "Punchbowl"'

Artillery and air5 field artillery battalions plus an 8-inch battery; 842 air sorties

37th and 38th FA (division), 503rd and 96th (corps) and a battery of the 780th; Fifth Air Force flew 842 close-support sorties and dropped 250 tons of bombs (Hermes; the West Point thesis gives the same sortie figures). W. G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (CMH, 1966), pp. 89, 96, as cited in Wikipedia, 'Battle of Heartbreak Ridge' (leads); U.S. Military Academy thesis, 'Fire and Maneuver: The 2nd Infantry Division's Assault on Korea's "Punchbowl"'

Rifle company strengthoften under 50 men

The thesis says some companies were down to fewer than 50 men; Gugeler records Company G, 23rd Infantry, at one time numbering only 23 men. U.S. Military Academy thesis, 'Fire and Maneuver: The 2nd Infantry Division's Assault on Korea's "Punchbowl"'; R. A. Gugeler, Combat Actions in Korea (CMH), ch. 17, 'Heartbreak Ridge'

Casualties

The U.S. 2nd Infantry Division and its attached French and Dutch battalions lost over 3,700 killed, wounded and missing in a month, nearly half in the 23rd Infantry and the French Battalion; the division estimated North Korean and Chinese losses at close to 25,000, a figure no other source can check. Certainty: fair.

North Korean People's Army (later Chinese People's Volunteers)

Casualties, North Korean and Chinese combined (U.S. estimate)close to 25,000

The 2nd Division's estimate, about half of it during Operation Touchdown, as reported by the U.S. Army official history and repeated by Gugeler and the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture; it is a U.S. estimate, not a count, and no North Korean or Chinese figure has been published. W. G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (CMH, 1966), p. 96, as cited in Wikipedia, 'Battle of Heartbreak Ridge' (leads); R. A. Gugeler, Combat Actions in Korea (CMH), ch. 17, 'Heartbreak Ridge'; Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, '단장의 능선 전투' (Battle of Heartbreak Ridge)

Chinese 204th Divisionunknown; 'suffered heavily'

Caught in the open by the 10 October tank thrust while relieving the North Korean V Corps; its losses are inside the combined 25,000 estimate (Hermes). W. G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (CMH, 1966), pp. 95–96, as cited in Wikipedia, 'Battle of Heartbreak Ridge' (leads)

U.S. 2nd Infantry Division, with the French Battalion and the attached Netherlands Battalion

Casualties, 2nd Division and attached units, 13 Sept – 15 Oct (killed, wounded and missing combined)over 3,700 (1,740 to over 3,800)

The official history (Hermes, as cited) and Gugeler give over 3,700 American and French casualties, and the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture about 3,700 for UN forces; the atlas's own caption reads the official history as over 3,800; a West Point thesis gives a far lower 1,740 for the battle. W. G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (CMH, 1966), p. 96, as cited in Wikipedia, 'Battle of Heartbreak Ridge' (leads); R. A. Gugeler, Combat Actions in Korea (CMH), ch. 17, 'Heartbreak Ridge'; Encyclopedia of Korean Culture, '단장의 능선 전투'; U.S. Military Academy thesis, 'Fire and Maneuver: The 2nd Infantry Division's Assault on Korea's "Punchbowl"'

Casualties by 26 September (first phase)over 1,670 in the division, over 950 of them in the 23rd Infantry

Hermes' figures at the halt of the frontal attacks; the West Point thesis likewise says the 23rd had lost nearly 950 killed, wounded and missing before Touchdown, with the French adding 157 more. W. G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (CMH, 1966), p. 91, as cited in Wikipedia, 'Battle of Heartbreak Ridge' (leads); U.S. Military Academy thesis, 'Fire and Maneuver: The 2nd Infantry Division's Assault on Korea's "Punchbowl"'

23rd Infantry and French Battalion togetheralmost half of the division's total

Hermes says the 23rd Infantry and its attached French Battalion took almost half of the division's casualties. W. G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (CMH, 1966), p. 96, as cited in Wikipedia, 'Battle of Heartbreak Ridge' (leads)

French Battalion, killed and wounded (26 Sept – 21 Oct)60 killed, nearly 260 wounded

The French Ministry of the Armed Forces' figure for the battalion's losses from its engagement on 26 September to its relief on 21 October. French Ministry of the Armed Forces, Chemins de mémoire, 'The UN French Battalion in Korea'

Medal of Honor recipients killed2

Pfc. Herbert K. Pililaau (Co. C, 23rd Infantry, 17 Sept) and Sfc. Tony K. Burris (Co. L, 38th Infantry, 8–9 Oct), both posthumous awards. National Medal of Honor Museum, Tony K. Burris

Then and now: how the ground has changed

The ridge itself is still steep, razor-backed mountain, but since the 1953 armistice much of it has lain in or beside the Demilitarized Zone, behind wire, minefields and military posts, and closed to visitors and researchers; no published survey compares its ground with 1951.

Weapons

North Korean People's Army (later Chinese People's Volunteers)

PPSh-41

PPSh-41

7.62 mm submachine gun · 1941–1950s (Chinese Type 50 copy in Korea)

At Heartbreak Ridge: North Korean and Chinese infantry held the ridge's bunkers with submachine guns, rifles and machine guns.

The Soviet wartime submachine gun, simple to make and fast-firing. China copied it as the Type 50, and Chinese assault troops used it in great numbers in the night attacks of the Korean War.

Caliber
7.62×25 mm
Magazine
71-round drum or 35-round box
Rate
about 900–1,000 rounds a minute
Photo: PPSh-41, National Museum of Scotland · 501ghost · CC0

U.S. 2nd Infantry Division, with the French Battalion and the attached Netherlands Battalion

M1 Garand

M1 Garand

Semi-automatic rifle · 1936–1958 (US standard rifle)

At Heartbreak Ridge: The 23rd Infantry and the French Battalion took the crest hills bunker by bunker.

The M1 Garand was the first semi-automatic rifle adopted as a nation's standard infantry weapon. It gave the American rifleman much more firepower than a bolt-action rifle, and General George Patton called it "the greatest battle implement ever devised."

Caliber
.30-06 Springfield
Effective range
about 460 m (500 yd)
Feed
8-round en-bloc clip
Photo: Armémuseum (Swedish Army Museum) · Public domain
M4 Sherman

M4 Sherman

Medium tank · 1942–1950s (US service)

At Heartbreak Ridge: Operation Touchdown sent the 72nd Tank Battalion's Shermans up the Mundung-ni valley on a road the engineers had built, catching the Chinese 204th Division in the open.

The Sherman was the most widely used American tank of World War II, valued for its reliability and ease of production. Specialized versions included the Duplex Drive (DD) amphibious tank and flamethrower conversions.

Crew
5
Armament
75 mm gun M3 (most early versions)
Weight
about 30 metric tons
Photo: Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

Paintings and photographs

Heartbreak Ridge seen from the north
Heartbreak Ridge seen from the north U.S. Army Signal Corps photograph of Heartbreak Ridge, seen from the north. U.S. Army Signal Corps (National Archives 111-SC-382926), public domain · source
Punchbowl, Heartbreak Ridge and Bloody Ridge
Punchbowl, Heartbreak Ridge and Bloody Ridge Map of the Punchbowl area showing Bloody Ridge and Heartbreak Ridge. U.S. Army, public domain · source
Sfc. Tony K. Burris
Sfc. Tony K. Burris Sfc. Tony K. Burris, Company L, 38th Infantry, Medal of Honor (posthumous), vicinity of Mundung-ni, 8–9 October 1951. American Battle Monuments Commission, public domain · source
F4U-4 Corsair over Korea, September 1951
F4U-4 Corsair over Korea, September 1951 A U.S. Navy F4U-4 Corsair about to attack a railway bridge in North Korea, September 1951. Marine Corsairs struck the North Korean lines before Operation Touchdown. U.S. Navy, public domain · source

★ Medal of Honor 2 recipients

Links go to the official records: the Congressional Medal of Honor Society and, where they exist, the service's own pages.

Free for everyone every year on its anniversary: September 13 – October 15.

Accuracy score: 60/100 (moderate)

How the accuracy score works

Sources and method

Battle of Heartbreak Ridge, 13 September – 15 October 1951. No U.S. Army staff ride handbook covers this battle. The course of the fight, the units, dates and hill numbers follow Walter G. Hermes, Truce Tent and Fighting Front (U.S. Army in the Korean War, Center of Military History, 1966), chapter V, 'The New War', which gives the ridge's peaks south to north as Hills 894, 931 and 851, Hill 931 1,300 yards north of 894 and Hill 851 2,100 yards beyond it, the 23rd Infantry's start from Hill 702 across the Sat'ae-ri valley, the French on Hill 868, and Hills 728, 485 and 520 relative to them. The attack on Hill 520 follows Russell A. Gugeler, Combat Actions in Korea (CMH), chapter 17. Also used: the U.S. Military Academy thesis 'The 2nd Infantry Division's Assault on Korea's "Punchbowl"' (from the division's command reports and the Eighth Army's 'Action on Heartbreak Ridge'); the Republic of Korea Ministry of Patriots and Veterans Affairs, Key Battles; the Encyclopedia of Korean Culture (단장의 능선 전투); and the Medal of Honor citations of Pfc. Herbert K. Pililaau (Company C, 23rd Infantry, Pia-ri, 17 September 1951; General Orders No. 58, 18 June 1952; Home of Heroes) and Sfc. Tony K. Burris (Company L, 38th Infantry, vicinity of Mundung-ni, 8–9 October 1951; General Orders No. 84, 1952; Home of Heroes, National Medal of Honor Museum). Placement: Hills 931, 894 and 851 are placed on terrain-model summits matching Hermes' order and spacing along the ridge; Hill 867 on a terrain-model summit about three miles southwest of Hill 894, as Hermes describes; Hill 1024 approximately, about four miles southwest of Hill 894; Hills 974 and 1220 schematically on the ridge running northwest from Hill 636. The other hills, the valleys and the unit blocks are placed schematically from the official descriptions. Bloody Ridge and the Punchbowl use their published coordinates. Positions are interpretive and should be read as approximate. Images from Wikimedia Commons (U.S. Army / National Archives, public domain).

Where the positions come from

Further reading