Battlefield Atlas
In memoriam · 1975

Sinking of the SS Edmund Fitzgerald, 10 November 1975

On 10 November 1975 the ore carrier SS Edmund Fitzgerald, then one of the largest ships on the Great Lakes (729 feet), sank in a storm on eastern Lake Superior about 17 miles from Whitefish Point, Michigan, with all 29 of her crew. She had left Superior, Wisconsin, the afternoon before with taconite pellets for Zug Island, Detroit, in company with the Arthur M. Anderson, whose crew tracked her on radar to the end. She sent no distress call. The cause has never been settled. The U.S. Coast Guard Marine Board (1977) found the most probable cause was flooding of the cargo hold through ineffective hatch closures, while stating that the proximate cause could not be determined; the National Transportation Safety Board (1978) found the probable cause was sudden massive flooding of the hold due to the collapse of one or more hatch covers. The Lake Carriers' Association, and Captain Cooper of the Anderson ('My own opinion is that she bottomed out on a shoal'), held that she struck Six Fathom Shoal off Caribou Island; others, including a 2012 forensic study by Sean Kery and Ben Fisher, report no sign of grounding damage on the exposed stern. Some point to exceptionally large waves (the 'three sisters' of Great Lakes lore); a 2006 NOAA reanalysis (Hultquist, Dutter and Schwab) found significant waves above 25 feet, with the worst conditions near the time and place of the sinking (by its account, six hours earlier or later she would have missed the worst), and that the largest individual waves could have reached about 46 feet; it does not name a cause. Others, citing a 1978 deposition about a repeatedly loose keel, argue for structural failure; diver and historian Ric Mixter holds that she broke on the surface after hatches collapsed. The loss led to new requirements for survival suits and depth finders, stricter load lines and annual fall inspections, and a new LORAN-C positioning system on the Lakes. Gordon Lightfoot's 1976 song made the wreck widely known. This map is a memorial. The crew, as listed by the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum: Michael E. Armagost, Third Mate; Fred J. Beetcher, Porter; Thomas D. Bentsen, Oiler; Edward F. Bindon, First Assistant Engineer; Thomas D. Borgeson, Maintenance Man; Oliver J. Champeau, Third Assistant Engineer; Nolan S. Church, Porter; Ransom E. Cundy, Watchman; Thomas E. Edwards, Second Assistant Engineer; Russell G. Haskell, Second Assistant Engineer; George J. Holl, Chief Engineer; Bruce L. Hudson, Deck Hand; Allen G. Kalmon, Second Cook; Gordon F. MacLellan, Wiper; Joseph W. Mazes, Special Maintenance Man; John H. McCarthy, First Mate; Ernest M. McSorley, Captain; Eugene W. O'Brien, Wheelsman; Karl A. Peckol, Watchman; John J. Poviach, Wheelsman; James A. Pratt, Second Mate; Robert C. Rafferty, Steward; Paul M. Riippa, Deck Hand; John D. Simmons, Wheelsman; William J. Spengler, Watchman; Mark A. Thomas, Deck Hand; Ralph G. Walton, Oiler; David E. Weiss, Cadet; Blaine H. Wilhelm, Oiler.

Open the interactive map8 stages on today's satellite map

A memorial map, free for everyone. It appears in the atlas each year on 10 November; this page and the map stay open by link all year.

SS Edmund Fitzgerald
SS Edmund Fitzgerald — Greenmars — CC BY-SA 3.0

Stage by stage

  1. 9 November 1975, about 2:15 PM

    Leaving Superior

    At the Burlington Northern Railroad Dock No. 1 in Superior, Wisconsin, the Edmund Fitzgerald finishes loading 26,116 long tons of taconite pellets bound for Zug Island, Detroit (the Coast Guard report says Detroit), and departs at about 2:15 PM (the U.S. Coast Guard's time; the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum gives about 2:30). Her master is Captain Ernest M. McSorley; she carries a crew of 29. At about 4:30 PM the Arthur M. Anderson, under Captain Jesse 'Bernie' Cooper, leaves Two Harbors, Minnesota, with a similar cargo for Gary, Indiana. The two ships are soon in radio contact, 10 to 20 miles apart, the Fitzgerald generally ahead. A gale warning is issued that evening.

  2. 10 November 1975, 1–7 AM

    The northern route

    With storm warnings issued at about 2 AM on 10 November, both masters leave the recommended downbound lanes and take a northerly route to use the lee of the Canadian shore: north-east south of Isle Royale, then east along the north shore. The Coast Guard report places the Fitzgerald about 20 miles south of Isle Royale at 1 AM and about 45 miles north of Copper Harbor, Michigan, at 7 AM. The storm, tracking north-east from the Plains, is now over Lake Superior.

  3. 10 November, about 12:50–1:50 PM

    Off Michipicoten

    Around midday the Fitzgerald is about 17 miles north-north-west of Michipicoten Island, with the Anderson some 8 miles astern off Otter Island. By about 1:50 PM the Fitzgerald is 2.5 to 3 miles south-west of Michipicoten and turns down toward Whitefish Point; McSorley tells the Anderson she is 'rolling some' but will continue on. Winds are shifting to the north-west and rising behind the ships.

  4. About 3:30 PM

    Past Caribou Island

    The Fitzgerald passes north and east of Caribou Island; Captain Cooper later said he believed the Fitzgerald "passed right over that 6-fathom spot" — Six Fathom Shoal, off the island's north end — a statement the Coast Guard Marine Board found "not supported by the evidence." At about 3:30 PM McSorley radios the Anderson, as the Coast Guard report records it: "I have a fence rail down, have lost a couple of vents, and have a list." He says he will check down (slow) so the Anderson can close the distance, and that both of his pumps are running.

  5. About 4:10–5:30 PM

    Blind in the storm

    At about 4:10 PM the Fitzgerald reports both radars out and asks the Anderson to keep track of her and give her navigational help. The Whitefish Point radio beacon is reported not operating. Between 5 and 5:30 PM McSorley tells the ship Avafors of a 'bad list' and 'heavy seas over the deck.' At 5:28 PM the Anderson fixes her position 10.5 miles east of Caribou Light, with the Fitzgerald 15 miles ahead and Whitefish Point 35 miles beyond her.

  6. About 7:10 PM

    "We are holding our own"

    At about 7:10 PM, with the Fitzgerald some 10 miles ahead, the Anderson calls her about other traffic ahead and asks how she is doing. The reply, the last ever heard from the Fitzgerald, is recorded in the Coast Guard report: "We are holding our own." A few minutes later, at about 7:15 to 7:20 PM, she is gone from the Anderson's radar and cannot be seen when snow squalls clear. She sank about 17 miles from Whitefish Point, in 530 feet of water just north of the international boundary, with no distress call. All 29 men aboard were lost.

  7. 10–13 November 1975

    The search

    The Anderson reports the loss to the Coast Guard at 8:32 PM. A Coast Guard HU-16 aircraft is on scene by 10:53 PM, followed by HH-52 helicopters and a Canadian C-130. At the Coast Guard's request the Anderson, nearing Whitefish Bay, turns back into the storm, and the William Clay Ford follows from Whitefish Bay; the Hilda Marjanne tries but turns back to anchorage. The Coast Guard tug Naugatuck and the 40-foot boat CG 40573 search the bay, and the buoy tender Woodrush sails from Duluth. On the morning of 11 November the Anderson sights a lifeboat and part of the other (at 8:07 and 9:05 AM). The lifeboats are recovered near Coppermine Point, Ontario: the William R. Roesch takes the No. 1 piece about 2 miles north-west of the point, and the fishing boat James D. the No. 2 boat near it. The two life rafts are recovered by the Roger Blough (9:42 AM) and an Ontario Provincial Police shore party; the report does not give where. No survivors or bodies are found. The active search is suspended on the night of 13 November.

  8. 14 November 1975 – 1995

    Found, and remembered

    On 14 November a U.S. Navy aircraft using a magnetic anomaly detector finds a strong contact near 47°00.5'N, 85°06'W. Sonar surveys by the Woodrush confirm two large pieces, and in May 1976 the Navy's unmanned submersible CURV III photographs the wreck, lying in two main pieces in about 530 feet of water in Canadian waters. What sank her is still disputed (see Overview). On 4 July 1995 the ship's bronze bell was raised by an expedition of the Great Lakes Shipwreck Historical Society, the National Geographic Society, the Canadian Navy, Sony and the Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians, with the support of the crew's families; diver Bruce Fuoco placed a memorial bell inscribed with the names of all 29 men on the wreck. The original is displayed at the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum, Whitefish Point, as a memorial to the 29.

Photographs

SS Edmund Fitzgerald
SS Edmund Fitzgerald The Edmund Fitzgerald in 1971. Greenmars — CC BY-SA 3.0 · source
Upbound and in ballast
Upbound and in ballast The Edmund Fitzgerald upbound and in ballast; U.S. Coast Guard photograph. U.S. Coast Guard — public domain · source
The Fitzgerald's bell
The Fitzgerald's bell The bell raised on 4 July 1995, now a memorial at the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum, Whitefish Point. Deb Nystrom — CC BY 2.0 · source
Whitefish Point Light
Whitefish Point Light Whitefish Point Light, toward which the Fitzgerald was steering for shelter. U.S. Coast Guard — public domain · source

Sources and method

Sinking of the SS Edmund Fitzgerald, 9–10 November 1975. Times, positions, radio messages (quoted only as the report records them), search units and debris follow the U.S. Coast Guard Marine Board of Investigation, Marine Casualty Report: SS Edmund Fitzgerald Sinking in Lake Superior on 10 November 1975 with Loss of Life (1977), full text and page transcription, including the wreck position 46°59.91'N, 85°06.6'W and the Navy MAD contact at 47°00.5'N, 85°06'W; and the National Transportation Safety Board, Marine Accident Report NTSB-MAR-78-3 (1978). Departure, bell recovery and the crew list: Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum / Great Lakes Shipwreck Historical Society (shipwreckmuseum.com; crew list as reprinted by the Mesabi Tribune). Weather: National Weather Service Marquette (Fitzgerald storm research; Hultquist, Dutter and Schwab, 'Reexamination of the 9–10 November 1975 "Edmund Fitzgerald" Storm Using Today's Technology,' Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 2006) and NWS Marquette summary (MAD contact 14 Nov, CURV III 20 May 1976, bell 4 July 1995). Competing explanations: Associated Press, 'What caused the Edmund Fitzgerald to sink 50 years ago is still a mystery' (2025), quoting Captain Cooper, the Lake Carriers' Association's view, Kery and Fisher (2012), Ric Mixter and the 1978 Burgner deposition. Fixed points: Burlington Northern Ore Docks marker (Wisconsin Historical Society no. 192, HMdb); Whitefish Point and Caribou Island lights (coordinates from Wikipedia). The two ships' tracks are reconstructed from the times, ranges and bearings in the Coast Guard report and are approximate; Six Fathom Shoal (North Bank) is placed from the Coast Guard report's chart position (p. 85); the 1976 survey found it about a mile farther east. Michipicoten Island from Canadian Geographical Names; Coppermine Point from the original light site (lighthousefriends.com). Rule changes after the loss: Mining Gazette (2025). Ship blocks are drawn larger than life so they show at lake scale.

Where the positions come from